-
Halal Becomes Impermissible If Certainly It Will Cause Unintentional Sin?
Hello there, assallam u alaikum.
my question is that will a halal action earn a sin, if the doer while doing it was certain that it will cause him to do a Haram thing unintentionally?
For example, an atheist, who used to go to gym for years and as he used to have an excellent body, he used to feel feelings of pride and arrogance in him and he used to be filled with thinking that he’s superior than others and whenever he used to see a skinny man, he used to think “look at this poor stick, who can’t even lift 10kgs while i can lift 50kg with one hand, I’m the pride of manliness and these men are just disgrace to it” and other similar thoughts. his such thinking and feelings of pride are Haram and hated by Allah.
Now as he became Muslim, he understands that such thinking and feelings of pride are Haram. whenever he goes to gym, he finds himself often falling into same feelings, then he realizes that it’s sin and he removes them. but everyday whenever he goes to gym, he goes into feelings of pride for a few minutes until he realizes what he is doing is sin and this thing happens 6-7 times everyday. now when he is going to gym he realizes that if he goes to gym today, he’ll again fall into Haram unintentionally for a few minutes until he gets reminded.
Now as we know that an unintentional Haram is not harmful and no problem. but if someone knows that if he does something halal then he’ll certainly 100% cause himself to unintentionally fall into the Haram thing, the thing which his Lord doesn’t like that it happens, will this man be sinful for going to gym and exposing himself to certainly failing into unintentional Haram?
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi