-
Why Allah Ordered Violence
Why Allah ordered to kill people in the Quran? If people don’t want to believe in a book, does that mean they don’t have the right to live?
And whenever I ask this question I got response that God punishes people after he sends a prophet and people don’t believe. Yeah, but that’s exactly my point. People have their own lives, their own problems, their own responsibilities. May be they are not interested in your Text or God at all. And God is ordering to kill them?
-
5 Replies
-
Why Allah Ordered Violence
updated 1 week, 4 days ago
3 Members
·
5
Replies
-
We dislike the people who refute a fact when it is made evident to them. The government punishes people when it warns them of the consequences of their refusal of certain commands.
This is what God does to people who refuse to accept a fact that was made evident to them. It is not a matter of choice; they have to decide, based on rationality, why they believe or do not believe.
-
It was not so evident in case of Prophet Muhammad, was it? Like a person in the 7th century could have doubts about the Quran and Prophet Muhammad just as a person in the 21st century. How was it black and white? State never punishes people for the believes they hold. States take actions when they do something that harms others. They try to keep order and peace. There are people who believe Flat earth, but bcz of the fact that its a harmless believe states don’t do anything despite earth not being flat is the most obvious fact at this time.
Not believing in Prophet Muhammad was not harming anyone, was it?
What good does it serve to kill people of other religions and displacing them from the land they inhabited for centuries?
-
Like people at that time could have find no reason to believe in the Noah flood, in the Moses splitting sea. These are such things that one can believe if they want to but they can’t prove if that happened. The possibility that God can do such things doesn’t help much bcz the probability still remains the lowest. like you can be a believer of God and still a non believer of these stories. The question still remains that,”IF GOD EVER DID SUCH THINGS?”.
People of that time could have nothing special in the Quran, it’s the opinions what can anyone do about it? As reportedly in the quran and hadith they used to amde fun of it.
What did they do to deserve death??
-
There were people who never saw Muhammad, never heard of him never knew what kind of a person he is, who he is. and also the qiran wasn’t even in the book form.
how can allah order to kill people who are yet to read the Quran and check it’s authenticity???
-
Everyone is responsible for his or her beliefs and the knowledge they have and their behaviour towards the knowledge they receive about God and His prophets. If they have excuses for not believing in Islam, they will be excused, if they do not have valid excuses for not paying serious attention to the message of God they will be punished for their negligence.
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
