-
Proof Which Qirat Of Quran Is Qirat Al Ammah?
Let’s say in 20 years the reading of Qaloon becomes tawatur and the most popular reading in the world, what would that do to qirat al ammah? Would hafs reading no longer be qirat al ammah but Qaloon as it’s tawatur? How would we then know if Qaloon or Hafs goes back to the prophet….
-
10 Replies
-
Proof Which Qirat Of Quran Is Qirat Al Ammah?
updated 8 months, 1 week ago
4 Members
·
10
Replies
-
Qirat Ammah has been recorded in the history as a historical fact. Any change now doesn’t make a difference.
-
How do you know that qiraat al ammah never used to be Qaloon and only later hafs got popular?
-
-
Qirat Ammah, the name itself suggests that it has been a public Qirat, Muslims everywhere follow it, and all Tafseer literature is based on it. Every Hafiz, scholar, and common Muslim follows it. Other Qirat could never accepted as Aam. They were known to only a few Qari and scholars.
There is no evidence that what is taught in the name of Hafs, got popular at any point in time, and before it, there were differences. There is no evidence that the consensus on Qirat developed later.
-
Are any hadiths showing the narrative that a recitation or oder of surahs we see it today which was diff from the early recitation revealed (qiraat al ammah)?
-
No. There is no hadith to prove this statement.
-
So how can we believe that it did happen
-
I heard that the hafs was not widely accepted before some centuries it was duri which was the most prominent is it correct? If yes than the whole idea that hafs was the one with tawatur gets crushed? @Irfan76 @codename.AJK
-
According to Ghamidi sb Qirat ammah was already establsihed.
-
What do mean can u explain ? But we see hafs become prominent after ottomon
-
thats not true,.
Please see Discussion 82903 • Reply 82965 and Discussion 108059
ask.ghamidi.org
Source Needed Where Hafs Said That He Didn't Use Ikhtiyar - Ask Ghamidi
Does anyone know where hafs has said he doesn't use iktiyar?
-
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
