-
Ghamidi View And Other Scholars
I have a doubt that I am following th wrong.
As ghamidi sahab has views that conflict with key beliefs such as meraj and hazrat essa and imam mahdi etc.
I no way shape or form I am saying that Ghamidi sahab is stupid. Just that I see people say that he rejects authentic hadiths which makes me doubt whether I am following the right thing.
I am on a kind of see saw first I didn’t like ghamidi views then I got into them then I felt it was wrong then felt it was right and now feeling they could be wrong.
I don’t what to do as I tried to follow options that make sense but as a layman that was too exhausting.
Please give advice
-
5 Replies
-
Ghamidi View And Other Scholars
updated 2 weeks, 1 day ago
3 Members
·
5
Replies
-
That’s because you’re concerning yourself with the implications not the basic rules. Take the view on hazrat Esa. A common charge will be the whole ummah believes he was lifted to the skies.( not entirely true) But his view on this subject should be first understood by his approach towards consensus ‘ijmah” as a source of religion. How do u find his reasonin on it being not a source of religion. Try understanding and evaluating his basic approach towars religion. Stop divulging into the specifics outright.
(Views on mahdi and more aren’t entirely unique. Much falsehoo is spread in order to discredit him)
-
@Muhammad09 why do people say he is hadith rejected?
-
Ask the people who claim it. For him, Prophet Muhammad is the source of religion. He gave religion to us in the form of Qur’an and Sunnah. He doesn’t ‘reject’ them outright. His book Mezan has scores of them.
-
Raheel sb,
I appreciate your skepticism regarding Ghamidi sb’s opinions—it’s a healthy approach. After all, no scholar is beyond error, including Ghamidi sb or anyone else.
The key is that the arguments are available. You can study them, understand their reasoning, and compare them with those of other scholars. Whichever view you find more convincing, follow that sincerely. At the end of the day, the test of life is judged based on a person’s own belief, effort in seeking the truth, and their individual capacity.
The theological debates you’ve mentioned—while interesting—don’t determine one’s entry into Jannah. They belong to the academic domain. For the average Muslim, there’s no need to get entangled in them.
Focus instead on your worship, strengthening your faith, and doing good deeds. These are the real essentials for every believer.
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
