-
Actions Being Prohibited After Friday Azan
Assallam u alaikum,
My question is that, as quran tells in (62:9-10)
Does other activities become prohibited themselves during this time? Or this only tells that we should hurry towards prayer instead of work?. If for example someone does a service of helping someone during this time like tyre changing, would the remuneration of this service also be Haram earning?
Because if at this specific time, if the activity of changing tyre without any urgency, was prohibited, then wouldn’t the earning of this specific act also become prohibited?
-
11 Replies
-
Actions Being Prohibited After Friday Azan
updated 1 day, 15 hours ago
2 Members
·
11
Replies
-
No prohibited, but undesirable.
-
@Irfan76 sir would such earning be undesirable to use? As this article suggests?
https://questionsonislam.com/question/earning-person-who-does-not-perform-five-daily-prayers-or-friday-prayer-halal
Sir the similar question would come about the work a person does in the last minutes of, for example asr prayer, which cause him to miss asr prayer. Earning of that work also, would be undesirable to use?
-
Since nothing is prohibited or haram, therefore earning is not haram, but is inappropriate that God is calling and man is not paying heed to it.
-
@Irfan76 and so sir in a similar way, if a person who does a good action or deed towards me in kindness during this same sensitive time, where he was required to not do them and instead go towards prayer (either Friday, or towards the end time of any other prayer) . Can I reward their action? If I feel like reciprocating good deed with a money reward, kharchi. Will it be allowed for me?
-
You are not responsible for others’ actions. You can give your favour, of course. Only business should be stopped, not other good actions.
-
@Irfan76 and so sir in a similar way, if a person who does a good action or deed towards me in kindness during this same sensitive time, where he was required to not do them and instead go towards prayer. Can I reward their action? If I feel like reciprocating good deed with a money reward, kharchi. Will it be allowed for me?
-
Sir this article tells about that earning during that time is also Haram… Would the earning also become undesirable to use sir?
-
@Irfan76 sir here business, as entailed by quran means any other work or exertion that can cause hindrance and missing of Friday prayer.
My question is about for example Friday azan happened, and it was disallowed for my friend to do modification on my bike, as this would cause hindrance in his Friday prayers, but still he did it on my bike out of love, and his prayer got delayed. Now when I remember his favor of modification of my bike, I feel like repaying it with a gift. But now I feel that, if his action of modifying my bike AT THAT time was disallowed (due to it being hindrance in his friday prayer) , then would my giving of gifts as a return for that action be lawful? As giving a gift for reciprocating that action is same as remuneration over an action. If remuneration of disallowed thing is not allowed to use, then me giving him gift as a return of that particular action (which was disallowed at that time) also be disallowed for him to use? Or disallowed for me to give? Would it be like disallowed/Haram earning?
-
Again, you are not responsible for what others’ actions. If they do not fulfil their duties, it is between them and God. You can respond to their actions as you like.
Still, if you do not want to, don’t do it. Deen does not oblige you not return a favour.
-
@Irfan76 sir if I return the favor of that action that he performed about modification of bike (at the time when he should be going towards Friday prayer). Would my return gift be sort it Haram /impure earning for him?
-
The answer is already provided.
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
