-
Are Previous Prophets A Hujjah For Us?
Were the courts of God established with prophets like the messiah عليه السلام or Musa عليه السلام an argument for the quraysh who weren’t even there? Are they an argument for us?
-
6 Replies
-
Are Previous Prophets A Hujjah For Us?
updated 4 years, 5 months ago
3 Members
·
6
Replies
-
Yes to both.
-
How- they didn’t happen before our eyes? Isn’t our argument 1 the Quran is true therefore these things happened. And not 2 Musa عليه السلام had the sea split for him therefore islam is true. For the Jews it was the second argument I gave right?
-
It all comes down to establishing Quran as a Zaria Ilm?
-
I mean, its the same for Jews as well as it is for us so 1 and 2 both. I think.
-
Yeah- so the prophets themselves and the courts they established inherently aren’t a hujjah/ the Quran is
-
-
You’re confusing hujjah with itnam-e-hujjah. Hujjah simply means proof. Prophets use these proofs to perform itmam-e-hujjah (culmination of proof). The stories of prophets mentioned in the Quran are those that it’s direct addressees were already aware of. Quran mentions them as evidence – and that evidence is as true for us as it’s direct addressees.
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
