-
Law Of Messengers
Ghamdi Saab says rasuallah can’t be killed by munkreen but at one when there is rumour at the time of uhud about rasuallah death Allah says if ur messenger died in battlefield u will turn away from the Deen why Allah show this possibility
-
7 Replies
-
Law Of Messengers
updated 3 years, 1 month ago
5 Members
·
7
Replies
-
I think that you might have misunderstood something. Please share a reference so that your question could be understood in context.
-
Its very simple ghamdi Saab rasool always dominate their mukhatabeen and they can’t kill them but at the time of uhud battle their is rumour that that rasuallah dead then Allah reply supposed rasuallah dead to turn back to Deen my question is why Allah display the possibility being killed by munkreen
-
Please see:
-
Bahut simple BAAT munkreen ke hatho Kabhi rasool Ka qatal Nahi Woh lazim galaba pateh hai magar Allah be phir uhud Mai jab yeh afwaah uthi ke rasuallah shaheed hue Tu Allah nai yeh kyu Kaha agaar thumare rasool ko maut ya qatal hojae Tu kya tum Apne Deen se hath jaooge
-
Discussion 31434 • Reply 34744
Please read this specific response and the whole thread too
-
The verse of Aal-e-Imran you’re referring to do not describe any principle of itmam-e-hujjah. These verses are more directed toward the Sahaba and are an explanation of this fact that Iman/faith in isolation is not something that should depend on whether prophet lives or die, if one believes in a Prophet then one is ought to show the same level of faith whether or not Prophet lives among them. Therefore, there is no sense in taking it out of context and extract an independent law out of it. There were other verses in Aal-e-imran that describe the whole incident of uhad and the rationale why it all happened i.e. for ‘tamheez’ of Sahab as a part of law of test and trial (ibtila) of Allah. This has been discussed at length in the following lectures:
Discussion 22229 • Reply 22235
Suran Rad describes the actual principle of itmam-e-hujjah very clearly, please see this:
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
