-
Are Lucid Dreams Haram?
I want to convey this message to respected Javed Ahmad Ghamidi. There are special dreams called lucid dreams in which you know you are dreaming and control many things. I came to know that some Ulama thinks that this is haram. What are your thoughts?
-
10 Replies
-
Are Lucid Dreams Haram?
updated 2 years, 8 months ago
5 Members
·
10
Replies
-
Can you provide specifics why they consider it haram?
It will good if you can provide any reference for it. -
I am not sure because some say if you think it is bad so it is bad otherwise it is not. Some say it is impossible as Allah takes consciousness. So I want to know views on it.
-
A lucid dream is still a dream while asleep, however, supposedly you’re aware that you’re dreaming and you can control your dream to some extent. In my understanding there’s nothing haram or halal about it – it’s just a dream. We will however try to get Ghamidi sahab’s opinion about it and post it here when available.
-
In recent Q&A Session with Ghamidi Sahab on Questions selected from ASK GHAMIDI Platform:
For answer to your question, please refer to the video below from 1:09:09 to 1:11:13
https://youtu.be/X1X2sxA_VqQ?t=4154 -
I think question is not well conveyed,
It is different from sleepwalking,
it is kind of creating and controling inception or illusions only within your dreaming condition..
-
I understand that the question wasn’t well understood, however, the response is principle based and still remains valid.
-
👍🏻
-
-
Question was about lucid dream, not practice, how one can be accountable for a dream?!
-
The general principle is still applied and you can consider lucid dream halal (since it is only a dream). The experts can guide you further.
-
-
Yes i was thinking the same. It is just a dream. Thank you for response
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
