-
Authenticity Of Sahih Bukhari And Musnad Ahmed
Salam sir why some people’s ask that sahi bukhari and musnad e ahmad was not written by them self’s
And also comment that
sahi bukhari was disapeared from history for a long time almost 100 years
-
5 Replies
-
Authenticity Of Sahih Bukhari And Musnad Ahmed
updated 2 years, 9 months ago
2 Members
·
5
Replies
-
Anyone can make any claims that they like. What evidence do they provide for their claims?
-
Sahi bukhari ham tak 4 isnad s phnchi
Ibrahim bin makil nasafi k muabik
Abu suleiman khattavi ne is bary m kaha k ham ne sahi bukhari ka aksar hisa Ibrahim bin makil nasafi s suna jisy ham s khalaf bin mhmad khyam ne byan kia
Ye ravi zaeef hai saqit ul hadees hai
Isi babat ibne hajjar ne apni kitab lissanul mezan me is per zoff ka hukam lgya
Iske ilawa ibne jozi ne hadis ghrny ka ilzam lgaya(abul hassan qinani ne kaha)
Iske ilawa Abu Al fazal majhool ravi hai ye doosra ravi hai q k isko sika khny wala khudhi majhool hal hai( ibne asakir ne tareekh e dimishk me Abu saeed bin unis missiri jo isko sika khny wala hai apni zindgi or wafat k bad 150 sal tak ghair majhool rha takreeban 200 sal bad samaani jo majhool ko sika khnay me majhool hai is ne apni kitab Al ansab me sika keh dia )
Iske ilawa Abu Ali jaiyani jinki paidaish(427) jis se ye nikal kr rhy hain abu Al fazal sales bin mhmad iski wafat 350 ki hai to ye 70 80 sal ka frk ho gya is waja s munkata ravi ban jata hai
-
Kindly c clips of hafiz atif( bukahri ki hakekat )and( musnad ahmad ki hakeekat) on u tube please
-
Sahih Bukhari is neither divine scripture nor a book of religion. It is a book of history. Hadith narrations contained in this book and other books of narrations do not add anything to the content of Islam. The content of Islam has been transmitted to us in the form of the Quran and the Sunnah. Other than established historical facts, all history reaches us through a handful of people and there can be differences of opinion about them. Besides, how any book of hadith has reached us is irrelevant. We verify the chain of every narration and understand these narrations in the light of the Quran and the Sunnah.
For details please see:
-
Yes agreed thnx
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
