-
Is Knowingly Done Shirk Forgivable In This Dünya With Tawbah?
Hello there!
My question is that in in this ayah of Quran
“Indeed, Allah does not forgive associating others with Him ˹in worship˺,1 but forgives anything else of whoever He wills. And whoever associates others with Allah has indeed committed a grave sin.”
Quran 4:48
It says that Allah does not forgive shirk, and also Ghamidi Sahab in many of his videos said that “Agar jaante boochte Shirk Kiya gaya, toh yakın maafi ka koi imkaan nahi ”
So my question is that keeping this ayah in mind and what Ghamidi Sahab said that “Koii imkaan nahi”. does it talk about someone who came to Allah with Shirk in his account of deeds (the one who did shirk deliberately, and then died before sincere repentance) then, there’s no forgiveness for him??
Or does it mean in whole generality, that anyone who deliberately and knowingly (rebelliously) did shirk, then there’s no forgiveness for him (his tawbah and repentance won’t be accepted, because he is not to be forgiven)? And then even in this dunya, there’s no forgiveness for him at all
-
4 Replies
-
Is Knowingly Done Shirk Forgivable In This Dünya With Tawbah?
updated 2 years, 5 months ago
2 Members
·
4
Replies
-
KNOWLINGLY doing such a grave sin is rebellion, either way, so not forgivable.
-
@Irfan76 i mean sir then tawbah won’t avail him. For example someone does knowingly does this shirk the gravest of the gravest rebellion. But Allah gives him taufeeq and before death approaches him. He sincerely repents. So still his repentance won’t be counted at all? I mean he repents before death and does good deed and firmly holds on to Tawheed before death.
-
-
@Irfan76 i mean after doing such a grave sin, he does tawbah, sincerely holds firm in Tawheed and does good deed before death, still no forgiveness?
-
Sincere repentance of course deserves forgiveness. But it should not be because of death approached him. Then it won’t be sincere. So sincere repentance deserves forgiveness.
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
