-
Problem In Isolate Reports (Khabr-e-Wahid / Akhbar-e Ahad)
When we have accepted, we’ve to follow each and every commandment of Pbuh. Then why fikre e ghamidi don’t consider it right to accept any commandment. If a sahabi heard any commandment from pbuh, he tells this commandment to his wife, then how this khabre wahid is hujat to their wives?
-
5 Replies
-
Problem In Isolate Reports (Khabr-e-Wahid / Akhbar-e Ahad)
updated 2 years, 2 months ago
2 Members
·
5
Replies
-
It is not correct to say that Ghamidi sahab’s viewpoint does not accept isolate reports. The correct understanding is that due to a great chance of errors in isolate reports, such reports by themselves do not establish the veracity of the knowledge transmitted through them. Furthermore, an isolate report cannot be considered to override anything in the established sources of Islam i.e. the Quran and the Sunnah. This is quite logical. For further details, please see:
and
-
When commandment of changing the direction of qibla arrived and one group of Muslim was praying. Only one sahabi was enough for them to change the direction. If isolate retorts don’t override the quran and sunnah, then why sahabas changed direction?
-
At the time of Prophet Muhammad SAW it would be hard to believe that a Sahabi would deliberately relate something wrong. Even if someone made an error, that error would be immediately corrected by Prophet himself since he was present amongst the people at that time. If such an incident did take place, it’s quite obvious that the Muslims would give credence to Prophet SAW’s correction rather than insisting on the incorrect report by someone else. By asserting that Hadith narrations must be understood in the light of the Quran and the Sunnah which were undoubtedly given to us by Prophet himself, we are doing exactly the same – prioritizing Prophet Muhammad’s religious teachings over the reports of other individuals.
-
Is there any tawatur hadeeth which override the Quran?
-
Please see:
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
