-
Question On First Revelation Narrative
Questions with details is recorded in a video. Please see this YouTube video and give me your answers. https://www.youtube.com/live/8jvsZP7oBPA?feature=share
-
3 Replies
-
Question On First Revelation Narrative
updated 1 year, 5 months ago
2 Members
·
3
Replies
-
Give time stamp or write the question. its difficult to watch whole video. Perhaps the question may have already been answered in 23 question series. Plz see Discussion 44130
-
We have watched Ghamdi Sb 10 videos on this topic and came up with some questions which were not easy to write. We also read the discussion thread you shared but our questions are not answered there as well
We decided to record them so you can understand exactly what our questions are. I believe this is the best way for anyone to address our thoughts.
-
Are these your question? if not please refine them so it can be taken care of
1) If dream of prophet is also revelation, and Ghamidi sb say surah Alaq was recited in dream so why it cannot be considered a dream?
2) If surah fatiha is first revelation but it donot give idea about the responsibility of rasool?3) if surah mudassir can be revealed in two parts so why it cannot happen in case of Surah Alaq? Moreover, surah teen and surah alaq, surah qadar are complimentary to each other due to coherence of Quran. Hence Surah Qadar and teen tell us that surah alaq is first revelation.
4) If we dont consider surah alaq as first revelation then the similarity of Hazrat Musa is dissociated as hazrat Musa also keep saying “he cannot”
5) Ghamidi sb claim surah mulk, qalam, jinn, muzammil etc were revealed afeter surah faitha. However, due to context of surah mulk etc, it is impossible to say that these surah were revealed when Prophet saw was doing individual preaching.
6) Is there any evidence that the incident of first meeting with Hazarat Jibreel, it was about revealing surah fatiha?
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
