-
Itmam E Hujjat And Mirza'S Interpretation
Assalamualaikum!
Rejection of physical Mairaj of Prophet SAW, believing in the death of Jesus Christ while also rejecting the second coming of Jesus Christ in its literal sense, and not doing Takfeer of Qadiani movement. These are some very significant things that place Maktaba e Farahi closer to Mirza Qadiani’s interpretation of Islam.
I was wondering if Ghamidi saheb’s law of Itmam e Hujjat also has its roots in Mirza’s interpretation of The Holy Quran since he also ended up rejecting a large portion of Jihad. Please share your thoughts and study on this matter.
I must make it clear here that these mentions are not for mockery. I am genuinely startled by the similarities.
-
2 Replies
-
Itmam E Hujjat And Mirza'S Interpretation
updated 1 year, 6 months ago
3 Members
·
2
Replies
-
It seems you have not carefully read Ghamidi Sahab’s work or listened to his complete talks. None of his ideas have any roots in Mirza Sahab’s interpretations. The interpretations of Ghamidi sahab on the issues you mentioned are all firmly rooted in Quran, with strong corroboratory evidence from the Scripture.
To answer your question: No, the law of itmam e hujjat as explained by Ghamidi sahab is sourced from Quran, it has nothing to do with Mirza Sahab’s ideas.
The matter of bigger concern is the divergence of mainstream Sunni and Shia Islam from Quran on these matters, which should actually be probed.
Please also note that the right of takfeer of any people claiming to be Muslim has not been delegated to us by God. This practice is a mere display of self-righteous arrogance, and nothing else. It is God alone who will decide their matter on the DoJ, as no one else is the authority on earth to decide such matters after the Prophet PBUH.
-
Also see Discussion 52594 to grasp the basis of arguments
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
