-
Which Actions Invalidate The Ghusl?
Does ejaculation as the result of masturbation and nightfall invalidate the ghusl?
-
8 Replies
-
Which Actions Invalidate The Ghusl?
updated 2 months, 4 weeks ago
3 Members
·
8
Replies
-
Yes they do.
Please see the following thread for details:
Discussion 59633 • Reply 59638
ask.ghamidi.org
When Is Ghusl Required And Acts Which Nullify Wuzu - Ask Ghamidi
Is full ghusl required if someone masturbates, or just washing the area off is okay ? Does laughing or cussing invalidate wudu?
-
These are the same conditions that are determined by Ahnaf. What are the premises of these rulings? As per my knowledge these rulings are not inferred from Quran and sunnah. These are inferred by 2 narrations of Bukhari and Muslim. Please rectify me if I am wrong and let me know what are the other sources to infer that?
If you also consider those narrations as the source of these rulings then please clear my ambiguities about those narrations.
-
This is derived from Sunnah and jurists report consensus (Ijma) on these factors. Ahadith come in support of this consensus but not as a primary source.
Please read the following articles:
https://islamqa.info/en/answers/81949/when-is-ghusl-not-required
https://islamqa.info/en/answers/36865/do-i-have-to-do-ghusl-if-i-dont-ejaculate
-
-
So, we could say the primary source is ijma.
-
Yes, but this is not the Ijma of Interpretation which is not a source of religion, rather it is the Ijma as a mode of transmission of the content of religion from one generation to another i.e. How Sunnah is traced academically.
This is not related to the primary question but videos in the following thread can be watched for further details:
ask.ghamidi.org
From Where We Can Know That An Act Is Sunnah - Ask Ghamidi
in a video I have heard from Ustad Ghamidi that "we can find Sunnah in Fiqh books and he mentioned his own book", can he mention some other fiqh books
-
-
How can we differentiate between the Imja of interpretation and Ijma as a mode of transmission of the content of religion from one generation to another?
-
Ijma of interpretation is an academic one, it is about the understanding, the ijma on mode of transmission is of practice, perpetual practice.
-
Thank you so much for enlightening me.
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
