-
Sahih Bukhari Problematic Hadiths
My q is regarding 2 hadiths of bukhari
I still dont get these 2 hadiths
sahih bukhari 5010
Why would a demon or a jinn tell abu huraira ayata ul kursi? How come the jinn knew this? If it protects one from jinns by reciting it ; then why would a jin tell something so special to a human?
And why was that jinn even scared; he could easily escape, they are made up of energies as ghamidi sahib explained.
And as in Quran in surah rahman ; they are made of fire. This whole hadith sounds a little problematic.
Similarly there is another hadith 278, in which a stone runs away with the clothes of prophet moses etc etc.
How can we take such hadiths for being sahi?
They sound a bit ridiculing the deen a little if I may say so. Because if one reads these hadiths, they obviously will get many questions.
Im not saying that supernatural stuff didn’t happrn, ofcourse it happeend back in those days a lot probably, but these 2 incidents are a bit not realistic sounding. It seems something is wrong with these narrations.
Can you clarify these 2 hadiths for me.
-
1 Reply
-
Sahih Bukhari Problematic Hadiths
updated 1 month, 2 weeks ago
2 Members
·
1
Reply
-
This portion of Bukhari about the Fazail and Tafsir of Qur’an is not as authentic as other portion of his book.
The person who came to Abu Hurairah is declared to be satan. This is the adjective used both for jinns Ans humans.
The other story about the stone and Moses came from Jewish literature.
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
