-
Hadith On Sins
Please explain this hadith on sins as I read that minor stays minor but this says otherwise
-
9 Replies
-
Hadith On Sins
updated 1 month, 2 weeks ago
2 Members
·
9
Replies
-
Hadith is not cited in the post.
Once we establish a principle, an individual report cannot invalidate it. The report has to be interpreted in the light of the principle.
-
Ok this is the hadith in the attachment
-
This is not a hadith but an Athar narrated from Ibn Abbas. Tafseeri narrations are supposed to be inauthentic unless proven authentic.
-
I don’t understand should we don’t consider it
-
Correction: Tafseeri narrations are supposed to be inauthentic unless proven authentic.
If they go against a principle already established, then it has to be interpreted accordingly and if it is not possible, then it has to be rejected.
-
@Irfan76 first of all it has sanad sahih at the end in the bracket and secondally wouldnt sarkashi be considered and if sarkashi comes then minor would stay minor?
-
Tafseeri narrations are not categorised as Sahih or Daif. The reference is a book of Tafseer that is a secondary source and not a strong one.
When sarkashi is there, the man will be considered as sarkash. It is the behaviour that matters.
-
Could you describe the behavoiur @Irfan76 as I dont understand when a sin is considered sarkashi. Is sarkashi only for major sins?
-
Sarkashi is a rebellious attitude. One can tell by seeing it. It is when someone does not care about a directive, command, or law.
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
