-
Doubts
1. Downplaying Mutawatir Meaning in Hadith about Return of Isa (AS)
Where he’s potentially wrong or at least overstated:
Many Hadith scholars (like Ibn Hajar, Nawawi, Al-Qurtubi) argue that the meaning of Isa’s return is mutawatir, even if individual chains are Ahad. This is called Tawatur ma’nawi.
Dozens of Sahaba report various narrations about Isa’s descent — which gives it cumulative strength.
Rejecting this entire genre on epistemological grounds seems too strict — especially when belief in ghayb (unseen) includes accepting verified Hadith about the future.
2. Over-rationalizing First Revelation (Pehli Wahi)
What ustad Ghamidi sahab says:
The Prophet ﷺ was fully prepared, knew what was coming, and did not experience fear or doubt.
Possible Overcorrection:
While the Qur’an depicts the Prophet ﷺ as strong and certain, that doesn’t exclude a human emotional response in the first moment of receiving divine revelation.
Hadith in Bukhari about the Prophet being overwhelmed are not necessarily disrespectful — they may highlight the gravity of the experience, not weakness.
Even Musa (AS) trembled at the burning bush — it didn’t make him unprepared or flawed.
-
0 Replies
-
Doubts
updated 1 day, 6 hours ago
1 Member
·
0
Reply
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
Sorry, there were no replies found.
