-
The Story About Hazart Hajira
Javed ahamad Ghamidi does not agree with the normal majority version of the events during a question and answer session . he quotes from Quran. but did not give any other corroborative evidence’s from other sources. is there any hadith, in this respect. did his companion said any thing, where did this story originated from, if it is not authentic. is entire muslim umah wrong.
-
7 Replies
-
The Story About Hazart Hajira
updated 2 months ago
3 Members
·
7
Replies
-
Qur’an is the most authentic source. When it has told us the fact that when Ismael was placed there to reside, Ishaq was already there. It ends the debate. Secondly, Ghamidi saheb told that the story of Hajira and the infant Ismael being left in the desert by Ibrahim AS came from the Bible into islamic literature.
See the relevent verses of the Qur’an and decide for yourself. The argument that entire ummah is wrong holds no ground. The entire ummah can perceive something wrong, like the story of the first revelation in the cave of hira. Some traditions get famous.
-
Dr Irfan’s shahzad comments suggest will suggest doing or running between safa and Murva is wrong as well. Throwing of stones during haj, is all fabrication. Is QURAN does not mention any of these acts. Did our did not carry out any of these acts, or his companions. Are there any evidences to corroborate. The reason being that 99.9% of population is doing something else, while javed Ahmad suggesting completely opposite. Dr Irfan shahzad only replied in two short and shrift answers, which I was not expecting from scholar like him. We need something more substantial to argue the case. Moreover such a blunt answer could have been left alone, as it will not make any difference to population at large practices.
Thanks
-
Details are not repeated when they have been presented already. I refer to some videos for your knowledge.
Running between Safa and Marwa, and stoning the Jamarat are established sunnah. They have different reasons to be initiated.
-
@Irfan76 sir kia ap saee me bhagne ki reason bta skte hain please?? Ustaz ne is video me ni btaya
-
قربانی کے جانور کو قربان گاہ پر پھیرے لگانے کے بعد ذبح کیا جاتا تھا۔ یہ اس کی تمثیل ہے۔ یہاں مسلمان خود یہ پھیرے لگا کر اپنی قربانی پیش کرتا ہے۔ مگر اپنی قربانی کے عوض علامتی طور پر جانور کو قربان کرتا ہے۔
-
-
-
@Irfan76 g sir ye to theek hy. Iski smjh agai thi
Pr safa aur marwa k bech ik jaga 2 lights k bech me kehte hain k zra speed tez krli jae. Ya bhaga jae baqaida. Hazrat hawa se relate krte hain usko. Saray muslims usko amal me b latay hain. Is bhagne ki kia koi haqeeqat hy sabit sunnat me??
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
