-
Free Will
was watching hassan ilyas answering a questioner about free will. Hassan ilyas sahb said as we don’t know what God’s knowledge is so we have free will. As we don’t what his knowledge is so we can change what we don’t know. To change something we first know what it is.
But if we put the question this way.
At Time t1, God knows that Ali will commit a murder. and we don’t know what Allah knowledge is.
At Time t2, Ali commited the murder. And now we know what Allah knowledge was at t1 as the thing has happened.
The question is? Could Ali have done something different? Could Ali have avoided the murder? Well in that case God’s knowledge would’ve been proven wrong. God can’t be proven wrong. Whatever his knowledge is will be his actions.
-
1 Reply
-
Free Will
updated 18 hours, 33 minutes ago
2 Members
·
1
Reply
-
Always provide accurate reference when quoting a scholar or any other information.
Additionally, this question has been posted by you several times and has been addressed several times. If there is still confusion then please register for Ask Ghamidi Live session or Ask Hassan ilyas Live Session. It is perfectly fine if you are not satisfied with the answers provided to you earlier. You can explore other avenues for answer to this question.
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
The discussion "Free Will" is closed to new replies.
