-
Question About "prasad"
Assalamu Alaikum Ghamidi Sahab,
I live in India where many of my friends, classmates and neighbours are Hindu. During their festivals — like Diwali and Holi — they perform religious rituals at home and place sweets and other food items in front of the idol as offerings. Often some sweets are left right next to the idol (unwrapped), while others are packed. Sometimes they take the packed sweets and offer them to us.
I have a few related questions and would be grateful for your guidance:
1. Is it permissible for a Muslim to accept and eat sweets that were placed as offerings in front of a Hindu idol? Does it make a difference between unwrapped sweets left directly beside the idol and factory-packed sweets that are later distributed?2. If accepting such food is not permitted, what is the recommended practical course of action in a polite, respectful way that preserves friendship and neighbourly relations? Should one refuse, explain, or return the food?
3. If one feels uncomfortable accepting the offered food, is it acceptable to place it somewhere else (for example give it to an animal or dispose of it), or would it be better to refuse politely? Are there any ethical or religious considerations we should keep in mind about wasting food?
4. Could you please provide the Islamic reasoning or textual evidence (Qur’an/Hadith/fiqh principles) behind your guidance so that I can explain it respectfully to friends if needed?
JazakAllahu khairan for your time and guidance.
-
24 Replies
-
Question About "prasad"
updated 2 days, 10 hours ago
3 Members
·
24
Replies
-
Please refer to the following videos for detailed answers to these questions.
Please refer to the video below from 1:49:24 to 1:53:16
-
Isme video me to kha h ki khas apke liye mangawa h to usme to koi dikkat nhi kha ghamidi Sahab ne to mere papa k dost wo is trh k mauqe me khas dukn se le kar ate h khas to kha sakte h
-
Please reply krde @Umer25
-
Ji uska matlab hai kai woh jo khas mangwaya hai woh kisi Ghairullah kai naam pai nhi hai. Woh khaa saktay hain.
-
-
Please also refer to the video below from 9:08 to 10:36
-
Please also refer to the video below from 1:16:14 to 1:17:44
-
Brother, can you please explain the contents included in given video , as it is not playing due to some issues.
-
Eating any meal dedicated to a deity other than Allah is prohibited in Islam. We are not allowed to eat it, no matter if they are wrapped separately or not. We should convey our sensitivities to our friends in a polite way and mostly, rational people do understand and respect these religious sensitivities. In extreme cases, to keep others heart, we can take such sweets just as a token of appreciation and feed them either to animals or give them to other non-muslims.
-
-
Can we participate in such festivals without doing shirk or any immortality , and in diwali some friend burn crackers and in holi they apply colours can we do such things or we must avoid it .
-
We cannot participate in polytheistic rituals. Other than that, participating in social aspects of such gatherings is fine.
-
-
So , if my friend invites me on their festival so I can visit and please clear burning crackers or any other thing came in category of such polytheistic rituals , please clarify
-
Better ask your friends beforehand what polytheistic ritual in their religion is and what is not.
-
-
Ji maine bhi yhi pucha tha irfan shehzad sahab se ki mere pass k dost h wo holi me aur Diwali me khas dukar se kharidke leke ate h dene to usko kha sakte h to unhone kha ki laikin wo jo de rhe h wo to usi khushi k wajah se de rhe h na jo festival to maine unse kha ki wo mere liye khas dukan se leke ate h na jaise ghamidisahab ne kha to wo kha sakte h @Umer25
-
Please reply krde @Umer25 main sahi samjha hoon
-
Ji khas lanay ka matlab hi yahi hai kai woh kissi ghairullah kai naam pai nhi hai. Woh khaa saktay hain jaisay Ghamidi Sahab bh apna qissa bata rahay thaay.
-
Ye bataiye jaise giyarahi h to usme pura khana haram h ki jisme sirf fatiha kraya h wo haram h wo nazar ki pura jitna khana sb ki dawat jo krte h wo bhi
-
Khana agar Allah kai elawa kisi ki nazar hai woh toh khana Haram hai. Laikin waisay dua karwa lii hai toh us surat main khana haram nhi hota.
-
To giyarahi k khana kya h haram h ya halal pura khana jo dawat krte h wo bhi
-
Ji mairay ilm ki had tak, woh toh ghairullah kai Naam Pai diya jata hai. Woh Khana Haram hoga.
-
Nhi to pura khana haram h jo log dawat krte h to wha jake nhi khana chahiye bs is dawat ki k giyarahi ki isliye haram h
-
Khana bazaat-e-khud haram hoga. Chahay ghar main aaye ya aap wahan jaa kai khayen.
-
Nhi mtlb giyarahi k pura khana haram h ki sirf jisme fatiha kraya wo haram h
-
-
Laikin bhai giyarahi k fatiha to pure khane me thodi hota h thode se khane me hota h
-
Check karlain kai Allah kai naam pai diya jaa raha hai khana ya nhi. Agar Allah kai naam pai hai toh khana Halal hai aur agar nhi hai toh Khana Haram hai.
-
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
