-
If Prophet Needs Proves Why Cant Normal People To Believe
Assalamu Alaikum. I hope you are doing well. I have a few sincere questions that I’ve been reflecting on, and I’d really appreciate your scholarly perspective on them:
1. Allah showed direct signs and revelations to prophets through angels, but others are asked to believe without witnessing them — doesn’t that seem unequal or unjust in terms of evidence? If he wants to believe from anyone, it would be just to show equal signs and then ask.
2. The Quran says idols are not true gods because they cannot respond — yet Allah doesn’t visibly or audibly respond to us either. How should we understand this difference?
3. What is the purpose of miracles if they were limited to that era and not preserved as evidence for later generations?
4. What exactly makes the Quran “unrewritable” — what prevents it from being replicated linguistically or structurally?
5. Why is a woman’s share of inheritance 2/3 that of a man if not every woman gets financial support from a husband or not all marry? How is this justified in such cases?
6. Why was there no direct divine punishment (like that of Nuh’s people) upon the Quraysh during the time of the final Prophet ﷺ?
7. Why do we not find non-Muslim or independent historical records verifying the miracles mentioned in Islamic sources?
-
3 Replies
-
If Prophet Needs Proves Why Cant Normal People To Believe
updated 1 month, 3 weeks ago
2 Members
·
3
Replies
-
Please ask one question in one post. I take the first question of yours.
That is the scheme of God. He chose certain persons from human beings, showed them the unseen world, and asked them to stand witness to their people what they saw and experienced from God, and convince the people through logic and reasoning and signs of God. This is their test.
-
So, how this is justified? Showing unseen reality to 0.000001% and demanding test from the rest. Isn’t that against the principle of Justice!!! No Nabi had any chance of denying as they have seen the reality themselves with open eyes. And those who just have to associate things to an imaginable power. That makes NABUWAT questionable.
-
-
The world is not created on the principle of justice. People have different abilities, different opportunities to knowledge etc. This is a test. A prophet’s test is stricter than a non prophet. They are given no excuse and their judgment is made forthwith.
The truth or reality of prophet’s experience is made convincing to others through other verifiable signs, miracles and logical arguments.
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
