-
Is It Equal To The Great Sin Of Hiding Allah'S Religion?
Assalaam u alaikum, my question is that one day while I was preparing my question about something to ask from a scholar, regarding a ruling that I felt. And I was confused about how islam looks into such things. If Islam says A then it’s as usual as I thought, but if islam says B, then it triggers some indirect anxiety
My about to be fiance was talking to me and then the topic came about the name of scholar to whom I’ll ask my questions (she didn’t know what question I had in mind etc) .
I felt worried that if I tell her the name of scholar , what if she searches and sees my question being asked about that ruling. I was thinking that if this Islamic ruling she knows or she comes at the same point of confusion as I am then, due to some other circumstances she might get worried and restless (it’s a long process how).
So I did a tawriya and told another scholar name to whom I also ask question but not this one. So that she doesn’t think about this topic and go through the confusion I’m having and also spare her the restlessness and worry, if islam says B.
After doing that, i think about now and feel worried that.
Did i do the great sin of hiding truth of religion?
And now what should I do? Shall I just tell her the name of scholar I will ask from and correct that knowledge and leave her to her journey, that whether she reaches that video or not, is her own matter and upon Allah? Or I don’t need to do anything?
-
2 Replies
-
Is It Equal To The Great Sin Of Hiding Allah'S Religion?
updated 8 hours, 4 minutes ago
2 Members
·
2
Replies
-
This is not hiding a truth or religious knowledge. Your question is your curiosity, not hers. If she asks the same question out of her own curiosity and you hide the information, only then is it hiding a truth or religious knowledge.
-
@Irfan76 and sir sometimes when I am having some anxiety or thinking about this religious issue. And she asks me how am I..
I reply with “I’m feeling anxious because of a religious issue/thought” , then she asks “what religious thought are you having? “….
Then I reply with “Just leave it, I don’t want to discuss with you, it may cause confusion in you etc, and also you cannot help me give an answer for that”
So sir is saying her this and then choosing to not telling what issue am I thinking about, so that she doesn’t get confused, will this be considered hiding knowledge here?
-
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
