-
Learning Course From 3rd Party
Salam
I’ve been learning trading for many years. (It’s difficult that’s why still learning). There is a course (mentorship)of trading that is very expensive for me. But I found a party who is selling this course in very little amount of money. But the actual teachers don’t know this stuff.
Is it okay to learn like this. The only thing I went with 3rd party cuz the course was cheap for me. And I only want to learn from there. The reason is why I’m only learning this course is because I joined real course only for one month and because it’s expensive I left the mentorship. And in that month I’ve learned a lot of stuff and that improved my trading.
So question is same is it okay to stay with 3rd party to learn?
-
2 Replies
-
Learning Course From 3rd Party
updated 2 months, 1 week ago
2 Members
·
2
Replies
-
WalikumSalam.Your concern is valid, and Islam looks at this issue through the lens of rights, consent, and fairness, not just benefit. If a course or mentorship is being sold by a third party without the knowledge or permission of the original creator, then benefiting from it becomes ethically problematic, even if your intention is only to learn and the price is not affordable for you. The key issue is not learning itself—seeking knowledge is encouraged—but using someone’s work in a way that violates their right over it.
A helpful way to see this is to reverse the situation: if your work, skills, or content were being copied and sold cheaply without your consent, you would feel wronged, even if the buyer claimed good intentions. Islam places strong emphasis on not benefiting from something that clearly belongs to someone else without their approval. That said, your financial constraint is real, and Islam also recognizes hardship. The better path is to look for legitimate alternatives—scholarships, discounts, installment plans, shorter official programs, free or low-cost resources by the same teacher, or openly asking the course provider if they offer concessions.
( If you want, you can contact me and I’ll try to help you explore possible ethical ways to access learning resources or find lawful alternatives. I can’t promise results, but I can genuinely try to help you find a solution that keeps both your growth and your conscience intact.)
-
Thank you for your help and understanding.
I can’t find alternative solutions meaning in mentorship there are many private videos that aren’t available on YT or any other platform except in mentorship. From that videos there’s a lot to learn.
Also in this mentorship you have to stick with one rule one system and one model for your trading. But if you learn from other sources other mentorships It’s gonna be difficult for anyone cuz if you follow other mentorships, courses they gonna make it complex and they have their own strategies.
There are three sections in this mentorship, monthly, quarterly and yearly. Quarterly and yearly are more expensive and that’s why they put discount only on them and never on monthly.
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
