-
What Is Ghamidi Sahab's View On Death Of Jesus (a.s)?
I have heard many people criticising ghamidi sahab’s view on islam, mamy scholars and people’s view is that ghamidi sahab practically reject the authentic hadith if it contradicts his understanding of Qura’n,
And also the most important part that Hazrat isa a.s was called back alive and will appear again in future, he denies it, on what basis he denies it? And on what basis his view is right from other scholars who have studied islam so deeply, and for many years, i am feeling conflicted here and i need help on understanding his point of view about islam, and how it is valid against other scholars, and denying ahadith and such strong beliefs is not a minor thing, it can mislead people in a very large scale, kindly help me through this
-
5 Replies
-
What Is Ghamidi Sahab's View On Death Of Jesus (a.s)?
updated 1 week, 6 days ago
2 Members
·
5
Replies
-
Ghamidi saheb is not the first to call into question the reported information about the second coming of Jesus Christ. In the times of the companion, it was not a popular notion. In the realm of research and knowledge, we find differences. It is a common practice, but our people are apprehensive.
See the following series of Ghamidi Saheb on the Second Coming of Jesus:
https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLvDnnnkYLWQfWAoTUoZB1qvlqeURjMRJD&si=0dBl1mb4TTIBkHCe
-
I know he is not the only one mentioning this,
My question is how it is valid? And even his opinion on general issues he have a really different point of view than most of the scholars, does he not follow sharia? The general shariah, did he make his own?My concern is how can we know his opinion is valid and it’s not leading us stray yes in the end we are the one following it so it depends on us, but my question is how do we trust his point of view which is completely different than any other scholar who have spent the same years to learn islam
-
This is only the arguments that can be valid or invalid. Listen to his arguments and of others and then you can decide whose argument is mad make more sense to you.
-
From his arguments, it seems like he says ahadith are essential for explanation, but they do not hold the same definitive authority as the Quran or Sunnah,
Why is that? Isn’t ahadith are words Of Prophet Muhammed SAW, why is that he believes it’s not given the same importance when Allah himself honoured him enough to tell us to take his words and follow him? Since he is the embodiment of Quran, its conflicting me and it seems disrespectful to Prophet Muhammed (saw) aswell :/
-
Please learn Ghamidi saheb’s views on Hadith. It is kufr to disregard the saying of the prophet. The sayings of the prophet are indirectly reported, those are not his words but of the narrators. Therefore we have to investigate the authenticity of hadith and by comparing them with Qur’an we accept them as correctly reported or reject them as misreporting.
Watch his video series on Hadith Kia hai.
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
