-
Punching In Anger: Permissible Or Sin?
My question is: If a person feels extremely angry and has the strength to act violently, yet restrains themselves so that nothing outwardly appears, but internally feels burning anger, is it permissible for them to release that anger by hitting a hard surface, like a wall or the floor, without harming anyone? I consider myself fully under God’s control and believe that I cannot cause harm, but I want to know if doing this would be considered a sin.
-
2 Replies
-
Punching In Anger: Permissible Or Sin?
updated 1 week, 6 days ago
2 Members
·
2
Replies
-
Wa alaikum assalam,First of all, feeling intense anger is not a sin. Anger itself is a human emotion. You are accountable for what you choose to do with it. If you are restraining yourself from harming anyone, that already shows control and awareness.
Hitting a wall or the floor is not sinful in itself as long as you are not hurting yourself, not damaging someone else’s property, and not escalating toward violence. However, it is not a healthy long-term way to manage anger. When you hit something in anger, your brain links anger → physical aggression → slight relief. That relief releases stress chemicals and sometimes a bit of dopamine. Your brain then learns:
“Next time I’m angry, this is the way to discharge it.”
Over time, this creates a wiring pattern. The response becomes automatic and can intensify. What starts as hitting a wall can turn into hitting harder objects, hurting your hand, or reacting more quickly. The nervous system gets trained to escalate instead of calm down.
Anger is basically your nervous system in fight mode(alarm state). The goal is not to “explode safely,” but to deactivate fight mode.
There are better ways to redirect anger(they may seem too bookish and nerdy but tbh these are the most effective methods out there)• Change posture immediately – if standing, sit; if sitting, lie down. This signals the body that danger is over.• Cold water on face or wudu – physically lowers nervous system activation.• Slow breathing (4–6 pattern) – inhale 4 seconds, exhale 6 seconds. Long exhale tells the brain to calm down.• Walk away for 10–15 minutes – movement burns off adrenaline safely.• Intense but controlled exercise later
Or even you can pray
• Write exactly what you want to say but don’t send it.• Delay response rule – never respond while heart rate is high.
Or engage in a concentration demanding activity.
Anger usually peaks for about 60–90 seconds biologically if you don’t keep feeding it with thoughts. Most anger becomes intense because we replay the story in our head.
Also remember: suppressing anger is not the same as processing it. After you calm down physically, ask yourself:“What boundary felt crossed?”“Why did this trigger me?”That reflection reduces future intensity.
So no, you are not sinful for feeling anger, and hitting a surface is not automatically haram if no harm is done. But training your brain toward physical release can strengthen the aggression pathway. The stronger path to build is: anger → pause → regulate → respond consciously.
That is real strength — and it protects both your deen and your mental health. -
Thank you for your help.Your answer is in accordance with the Hadith, and I liked it.My opinion is also that a person can manage pressure to some extent.Thanks again.
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
