Ask Ghamidi

A Community Driven Discussion Portal
To Ask, Answer, Share And Learn

Forums Forums Epistemology And Philosophy Islam & Atheism Series اسلام اورالحاد سیریز

Tagged: ,

  • Islam & Atheism Series اسلام اورالحاد سیریز

    Posted by Ahsan on February 20, 2026 at 1:15 am

    Episode 1:
    Time stamp created with notegpt and deepseek

    00:00:10 – Series Intro: The Atheism Challenge
    00:00:35 – Ghamidi’s Methodology: A Personal Journey
    00:01:39 – The Rules of Engagement: Honesty & Reasoning
    00:03:18 – The Wrong Foundation: Superstition & Mythology
    00:04:52 – Rational Possibilities: The “What Ifs” of Science
    00:05:35 – Case Study: The Theory of Evolution
    00:06:28 – Big Bang & Multiple Worlds: More “Possibilities”
    00:07:15 – Premise-Based Arguments: Talking to a Muslim
    00:07:59 – Abstract Reasoning: From Plato to Hegel
    00:09:27 – The Gold Standard: Established Premises
    00:10:03 – Defining the Terms: What is “Knowledge”?
    00:11:22 – The Basis of Knowledge: Introducing “Meezan”
    00:12:04 – The Two Subjects of Knowledge: Self & Matter
    00:13:32 – Defining “Self”: The Inner Personality
    00:14:23 – Defining “Matter”: The Outer World
    00:15:13 – Manifestations of Matter: “Things” & “Potentials”
    00:17:36 – Studying the Individual vs. the Collective
    00:18:46 – Understanding “Potential”: The Seed in the Soil
    00:20:00 – Language as Proof: Nouns & Verbs
    00:21:37 – The Noun/Verb Connection to Reality
    00:22:38 – The Role of Intellect: Our Distinguishing Honor
    00:24:19 – The Doors of Knowledge: External & Internal Senses
    00:25:50 – How Senses Connect Us to Self and Matter
    00:27:10 – Existential Realities: The Sun’s Proof is Itself
    00:28:51 – The Starting Point of All Knowledge
    00:30:02 – Conclusion: Setting the Stage for Atheism

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4NjVjFh5Djw

    Ahsan replied 4 days, 2 hours ago 1 Member · 4 Replies
  • 4 Replies
  • Islam & Atheism Series اسلام اورالحاد سیریز

    Ahsan updated 4 days, 2 hours ago 1 Member · 4 Replies
  • Ahsan

    Moderator February 20, 2026 at 1:17 am

    Episode 2:

    Time stamp created with notegpt and deepseek

    00:00:00 – Opening: Second Session Begins
    00:00:23 – Recap: The 5 Key Points from Session 1
    00:01:45 – Q&A: Where Do Time & Space Fit In?
    00:02:52 – Answer: Time & Space as “Containers” of Matter
    00:04:33 – Q&A: Defining the “Internal Senses”
    00:06:16 – Answer: The “Sixth Sense” Explained
    00:06:44 – Q&A: Internal Senses vs. Superstition
    00:08:26 – Q&A: Do Existential Realities Need Proof?
    00:09:22 – Answer: Drawing Attention, Not Arguing
    00:10:18 – Q&A: What About Illusions (Like a Mirage)?
    00:11:35 – Answer: The Role of Intellect & Consensus
    00:12:59 – Q&A: Philosophical Doubts (Descartes & Hume)
    00:14:44 – Answer: You Can’t Argue with Bumping Into a Wall
    00:15:15 – Q&A: What Exactly is the Role of Intellect?
    00:16:21 – The Next Step: How Perception Becomes Knowledge
    00:17:33 – Introducing “Inspirations” (Ilham)
    00:18:38 – The Mechanism: Inspirations Meet the Senses
    00:20:24 – The Intellect is “Totally Enslaved”
    00:21:38 – Introducing Imam Farahi’s 7 Principles
    00:23:13 – Principle #1: Certainty in the External World
    00:24:58 – Analysis: Sensation Alone is Not Enough
    00:26:10 – The “Authority” That Links Effect to Effector
    00:28:29 – This Authority is the “Inspirations”
    00:30:21 – “Natural Reasoning”: Compelled & Unintentional
    00:32:08 – Knowledge is a Granted Power, Like Sight
    00:33:58 – Q&A: Is “Table” a Name We Learn?
    00:35:03 – Answer: The Name is Learned, The Reality is Perceived
    00:35:37 – Q&A: Revisiting the Mirage Example
    00:36:07 – Closing: To Be Continued in Session 3

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tfvj9ZU7VlQ

  • Ahsan

    Moderator February 20, 2026 at 1:21 am

    Episode 3:

    Time stamp created with notegpt and deepseek

    00:00:10 – Opening: Third Session Begins
    00:00:39 – Recap: The 7 Principles & Principle #1
    00:01:25 – Principle #2: The Self & The External World
    00:02:17 – The Key: Knowing “I am separate” from the world
    00:03:48 – This Separation is a Prerequisite, Not a Conclusion
    00:05:19 – Same Distinction Applies to Internal Feelings
    00:07:21 – Analyzing Subject vs. Predicate (Zaid is Black)
    00:08:48 – Distinguishing “Essence” from “Accidents” (Attributes)
    00:10:06 – This Distinction is an “Inspiration,” Not Learned Logic
    00:11:34 – The Foundation of All Certainty
    00:12:16 – Principle #3: No Attributes Without an Essence
    00:13:42 – Certainty in the Self that “Carries” Attributes
    00:14:23 – Principle #4: Inclination & Aversion
    00:15:48 – Principle #5: Judgments of Beauty & Ugliness
    00:16:27 – The Ability to Choose (Accept) or Reject
    00:17:49 – Certainty in Our Own Will & Freedom to Act
    00:19:06 – Life Depends on This Certainty
    00:19:47 – Summary: Knowledge & Will are Both “Inspired”
    00:21:07 – Closing: Applying These Principles Next Time

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1d9XyEpk2yY

  • Ahsan

    Moderator March 28, 2026 at 10:20 pm
  • Ahsan

    Moderator March 30, 2026 at 11:13 am

The discussion "Islam & Atheism Series اسلام اورالحاد سیریز" is closed to new replies.

Start of Discussion
0 of 0 replies June 2018
Now