-
Hadith Authenticity On Imam Hussain (rta)
Salam,
What’s the authenticity of this narration
“Hasan and Husayn as the Masters of the Youth of Paradise”
Similar narration about “Fatima being the leader of women in paradise”
Are these narrations authentic & why descendants of Prophet (PBUH) given such a high status despite none being a Prophet.
There were prophets of God who were murdered (e.g. Prophet Yayha), but leadership in paradise (as reported in above narration) is given to Nephews of Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) who grew up when Islam was dominant force in Arabia and didn’t faces much hardships for the rise of Islam as compare to early companions of Prophet (PBUH)
Thank you
-
4 Replies
-
Hadith Authenticity On Imam Hussain (rta)
updated 4 years, 2 months ago
2 Members
·
4
Replies
-
I hope the following comments of Ghamidi Sahab would suffice.
Please refer to the video below from 1:19:04 to 1:19:58
-
Thank you for pointing out to it.
These narrations made many Muslims to belief that Hazart Hussain (RA), was right in the battle of Karbala and consider it matter of faith, since he’s declared the leader of young men in paradise.
The bigger issue is not who was right/wrong rather how a historical event somehow is considered a matter of Imaniyaat due to above mentioned narrations.
-
You’re very right, Faizan Sahab!
It is indeed a tragedy that Imaniyaat and people’s fate are now decided on the basis of history and especially details transmitted through Akhbar-i-Ahad. But it is Allah’s great blessing that we have Quran with us; so that those among us who are true seekers of truth, can always refer to pure revelation.
-
-
Quran is the ultimate guide.
Thanks again @UmerQureshi
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
The discussion "Hadith Authenticity On Imam Hussain (rta)" is closed to new replies.
