-
What If A Judge Makes A Mistake In Giving Capital Punishment?
If a judge made a mistake in giving capital punishment- EG to his full knowledge and all of his evidences and his understanding the man deserved the crime (let’s say it was a murder)- but the man was actually innocent- what would happen to the judge. He has taken a man’s life and he never found out. On the day of judgement would he be held accountable for this since he had infringed upon someone’s life?
-
2 Replies
-
What If A Judge Makes A Mistake In Giving Capital Punishment?
updated 4 years, 5 months ago
2 Members
·
2
Replies
-
Response by Hassan Ilyas sahab:
-
So huqooq ul ibaad breaks down here right? Because that philosophy would dictate that a right has been infringed upon and it must be paid for. On the day of judgement (according to huqooq ul ibaad) if the judge made a wrong decision and only found out on qiyamah, then he will have to pay with his good deeds. This doesn’t seem fair so I guess huqooq ul ibaad requires a bit of nuance. Unintentional infringing of rights do not count.
-
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
