-
Where Did Prophet Ibrahim Sacrifice His Son
So where did Prophet Ibrahim AS sacrifice Prophet Ismail AS? According to Ustadh Sahab it is not Marwa or Makkah then.
-
7 Replies
-
Where Did Prophet Ibrahim Sacrifice His Son
updated 4 years, 3 months ago
3 Members
·
7
Replies
-
Please refer to the following link-videos:
-
JAK. But now more confused. Because in the video shared in the above thread Ghamidi Sahab said that it took place near Marwa. https://youtu.be/Ea5xA3AvD_c
-
What is the confusion, can you please elaborate further?
-
In the above clip Ustadh Sahab said (2:30) that Prophet Ibrahim AS took his family to Makkah after the sacrifice . After the birth of Prophet Ishaq AS. And the second clip he said that the sacrifice of Prophet Ismail happened near Marwa. (0:20)
-
it is quite possible that both events happened at different times. Sacrifice event could’ve happened earlier near Marwa and then latter proper settlement of the family. Since it was a dream shown to Prophet Abraham (sws) upon which he acted literally therefore, it is quite possible that this happened earlier and then settlement happened later based on true interpretation of dream. But the time gap between these two won’t be too long.
-
-
JAK. But how the same incident happened in two different places?
-
@Afia, which same incident took place in different place?
-
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
