-
Bibi Hajira And Safa Marwa
Did any muhaddes differ with the hadees of sahi Bukhari 3364 in which bibi hajira ran between two mountains….. When I gave opinion of Ghamidi sahab on this people are asking for reference.
-
2 Replies
-
Bibi Hajira And Safa Marwa
updated 4 years, 1 month ago
3 Members
·
2
Replies
-
I am not sure if any muhhadith has “disagreed” with the hadeeth, however as a principle, injunctions in sharia are not determined on the basis of hadeeth or agreements / disagreements thereof.
Sa’ee of safa marwa as well as the story of Bibi Hajira is covered in a lot of detail in the videos in the following post. There’s also a great book by Abdus Sattar Ghauri sahab that covers all aspects of this subject in a lot of detail. This book is also available in this post:
-
Kindly refer to following video for critiacl analysis of the hadith
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
Please sponsor Ask Ghamidi so that we can continue to provide and improve this community platform.
In the last 1716 days, 7,810 registered users have posted 61,339 messages under 17,405 unique topics on Ask Ghamidi.
