Episode 43:

1. Introduction and Summarized version for traditional narration of first revelation. From 00:00 to 1:58

2. Why you have different view than traditional view of first revelation? Critical Review of Hadith (https://sunnah.com/bukhari:3). Explanation of Verse 10:16. From 1:58 to 37:16

3. If you argue from verse 10:16 that there was no indication of prophethood from his behaviour then why he was too strong chracterwise? From 37:16 to end

https://youtu.be/Z9h-o0AOS2g

Episode 44:

1. Recap of Previous episode. From 00:43 to 2:20

2. Explanation of first revelation on Prophet Moses on basis of Surah Taha 9-13, Surah Namal 7-14. From 2:20 to 11:01

3. Comparsion between Prophet Moses’ first revelation and traditional view of first revelation on Prophet Mohammad (pbuh). From 11:01 to 15:28

4. Critical Review of Surah Alaq content and Shan e Nazool. From 15:28 to 22:33

5. Crtical review of later part of Hadith Sahih al-Bukhari 3 (https://sunnah.com/bukhari:3) and Sahih al-Bukhari 6982 (https://sunnah.com/bukhari:6982) . From 22:33 to 35:15

6. The reaction of Prophet Moses’ after first revelation and its comparison with the traditional perspective about the reaction of Prophet Mohammad (pbuh). From 35:15 to 39:16

7. Isn’t it strange that Prophet Mohammad (pbuh) went to a Christian for calming his mind? From 39:16 to 43:14

https://youtu.be/5Z25dJ7s82U

Episode 45:

1. Why is it necessary to question how this narration has been transmitted? Critical review of the chain of transmission. From 00:43 to 28:17

2. Mohadiseen point of view on this narration. From 28:17 to 32:30

3. Do scholars question the narrations in Bukhari? From 32:30 to 33:45

4. What are other academic questions which you have about this narration? Discussion about Sirat un Nabi. From 33:45 to 42:47

5. Introduction to the incident of first revelation written by Ibne Hisham. From 42:47 to end

https://youtu.be/rEX0fEMlyvc

Episode 46:

1- An excerpt from Seerat un nabi written by Ibn e Hisham. From 00:41 to 19:01

2- Discussion about Aitekaf in Cave Hira. Prophet Mohammad (pbuh) as a follower of Deen e Hanif. From 19:01 to 23:25

3- Activities by Prophet Mohammad during Aietekaf and after it. From 23:25 to 26:46

4- Incident of first revelation as written by Ibne Hisham. From 26:46 till end

https://youtu.be/UF9oybUsA0k

Episode 47:

1- Recap of previous episode discussion. Form 1:10 to 10:12

2- Continuation of narrative of first revelation written by Ibne Hisham. From 10:12 to 22:20

3- Meeting Warqa Bin Noufal. From 22:20 to 35:40

4- Comparasion of two narrations. A critical review about these narrations. From 35:40 till end

https://youtu.be/0qUrWlKc_IQ

Episode 48:

1- What is first revelation? Hadith about Surah Muddathir as 1st surah (https://sunnah.com/bukhari:4922). From 1:00 to 19:45

2- Another narration of Surah Muddathir. (https://sunnah.com/bukhari:4925). From 19:45 to 26:40

3- Third narration about Surah Muddathir. (https://sunnah.com/bukhari:3238) From 26:40 to 29:15

4- Analysis of these narrations. From 29:15 to end

https://youtu.be/oP5OX-wCe7I

Episode 49:

1- General Comments on hadith narrations. From 1:57 to 11:46

2- While analyzing Hadith narrations, do we question transmission of chains or Prophet Mohammad (pbuh)? From 11:46 to 13:18

3- What Quran says about incident of first revelation? From 13:18 to 25:52

4- Background of Surah Fatiha. From 25:52 to 28:33

5- Rationale of considering Surah Fatiha as 1st surah. From 28:33 to 32:45

6- Did other scholars also consider Surah Fatiha as 1st surah? From 32:45 to 35:00

7- What Quran says about incident of first revelation with reference to verse 53:1-11 From 35:00 to end

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ss3lOmd02IM

Episode 50:

1- Why there was pause in revelation? From 1:00 to 14:50

3- How dawah was given during early times? From 14:50 to 20:11

4- Wisdom behind pause in Quran revelation? From 20:11 to 24:15

5- How does Quran tell which surah is revealed later? From 24:15 to 31:35

6- Why does Quran call Prophet Mohammad (pbuh) “O who wrapped cloth”? From 31:35 to 39:43

7- Next level of dawah after revelation of Surah Muzammil. From 35:23 to end

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JAf34uH8MTM

Episode 51:

1- Why was there a 2nd pause in Quran revelation and what is the wisdom behind it? From 1:00 to 17:53

2- Why can’t it be argued that having fear after revelation is a result human nature? From 17:53 to 23:38

3- Isn’t it possible that continuous true dreams caused the fear? From 23:38 to 25:33

4- Is it necessary that incidents of revelation will be similar for Prophet Moses and Prophet Muhammad (pbuh)? From 25:33 to 27:45

5- You claim Prophets do not have any wish for prophethood. But Prophet Ibrahim seemed to ponder over things. How is that possible? From 27:45 to 32:01

6- Why Prophet Mohammad (pbuh) was having true dreams before prophethood? From 32:01 to 33:15

7- Don’t the events after birth of Prophet Moses show that people were aware that he is a Prophet? From 33:15 to 35:01

8- What is your point of view about the narrations on the events during journey of Prophet Muhammad to Syria? From 35:01 to 39:36

9- Why was Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) stopped from joining an event of music before prophethood? From 39:36 to 42:32

10- What is the reality of the narrations about the Cave of Hira? From 42:32 to 44:52

11- The Cave of Hira is a very small place and difficult trail, then how can a whole family go there? From 44:52 to end

https://youtu.be/Rc2b1lCQB_w

Episode 52:

1- What is your opinion about the narration that Prophet Mohammad (pbuh) went to the Cave of Hira after prophethood? From 00:58 to 3:11

2- Why did Warqa Bin Naufil perform tawaf? Did he believe in Islam? From 3:11 to 7:33

3- Why should we accept Ibn e Hisham’s historical record instead of a narration from Hazrat Aisha? From 7:33 to 14:34

4- Why is there no marfoo sahih narration of incident of first revelation? From 14:34 to 17:34

5- Why is there no consistency in your point of view because you have taken some ahadith from Zuhri’s narrations in your book Meezan? From 17:34 to 28:06

6- Has any other scholar criticized, academically, Sahih Bukhari narrations? From 28:06 to 31:10

7- Is there a possibility that the incident of revelation mentioned in Surah Najam happened after prophethood? From 31:10 to 34:04

8- Final Conclusion of whole session. From 34:04 to end

https://youtu.be/CyUK2CDf61c