-
11. The Concept Of Hoor In The Paradise
Following videos are from Ghamidi sahab’s Response to 23 Questions series. In these videos he analyzes the misconceptions that surround the the notion of hoor in the paradise (jannah).
You may also be interested in the following FAQ about the paradise (jannah) and the hell (jahannam):
-
5 Replies
-
11. The Concept Of Hoor In The Paradise
updated 4 years, 2 months ago
2 Members
·
5
Replies
-
Part 1 – Episode 53
00:43 Do you have any intellectual problem with the concept of hoor? Why you have different view?
09:34 Quranic verses (2:25, 24:26) talking about pairing in Jannah
18:31 Quranic verses (37:41-49, 38:50-53, 44:51-54, 52:17-20, 55:46-59, 56:10-24, 56:27-38, 78:31-35) which describe the women in Jannah
35:43 Definition of hoor
-
Part 2 – Episode 54
01:11 Recap of last episode
06:23 Discussion about hadiths which describe hoors.
11:04 It is said that weak narrations cannot be used for religious orders but can be used to understand benefits
13:16 Discussion about sahih bukhari hadith (https://sunnah.com/bukhari:3254 or https://sunnah.com/tirmidhi:2522)
16:30 Discussion about sahih bukhari hadith (https://sunnah.com/bukhari:2796 or https://sunnah.com/tirmidhi:1651)
18:13 Discussion about hadith in Musanad bin Ahmed (21528)
19:50 General comments about these hadiths
22:28 There are certain aspects in those narrations which imply hoor are different specie. What is your opinion about it?
30:25 Why do you have a different view about hoors as compared to others?
34:03 How do you interpret hoors as the same women of this world, who will reside in Paradise?
-
Part 3 – Episode 55
1:00 What do traditional scholars say about hoor? Why do they consider hoor as a separate being?
29:50 The translation of Hoor by Shah Abdul Qadir
31:39 Meaning of Anshahunnah
32:35 Meaning of فَجَعَلۡنٰهُنَّ اَبۡكَارًاۙ and relation with Ansha hunna
37:15 Opinion of Ibn e Kasir
-
Part 4 – Episode 56
01:12 How do modern scholars interpret the concept of Hoor?
20:16 Imam Razi died in 500 Hijri. How is it possible that the opinion of Tabaiin was reported by Imam Razi?
24:28 Opinion of Maulana Abu Ala Maududi about Hoors
-
Part 5 – Episode 57
1:09 What is the basis of your argument about Hoors?
13:55 In Farahi school of thought, it is believed that Quranic verse cannot have more than one interpretation. Then what happened to this principle in the concept of Hoor?
18:09 Since it is mutashabiha, then should we infer the meaning of Hoor as the women we know?
19:27 Why Ghamidi sahab uses traditional and historical narrative in his favor?
23:31 Why do Ghamidi sahab interpret the hadith Musanad bin Ahmed (21528) as ruya? Why does Ghamidi sahab accept this narration as sahih?
35:00 How is it possible that thousands of Hours will exist? (Opinion about https://sunnah.com/ibnmajah:2780 and similar narratives)
37:49 Opinion on narration used by Al-Tabarani
40:54 Why there is no similar reward for women as Hoors for men?
43:22 What is the actual meaning of the word ‘Hoor’?
44:45 If ‘Hoor’ refers to white-skinned women, isn’t it discriminatory?
46:15 Why there is no concept of Hoor in previous books?
48:50 What kind of a life will people lead in Hell?
49:56 Concluding remarks
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
The discussion "11. The Concept Of Hoor In The Paradise" is closed to new replies.
