-
Regarding Conditional Forgiveness Of Allah Swt
It’s stated That Allah Swt forgive only sins related to Him not others (that is related to among fellow human beings )what is the basis for this point of view? while Quran is stating differently at several places that He will forgive all sins. Please clarify ?
-
10 Replies
-
Regarding Conditional Forgiveness Of Allah Swt
updated 3 years, 3 months ago
5 Members
·
10
Replies
-
Kindly see Umer sb responses in following thread
Discussion 33804 -
Overall Quran directives of justice on the day of judgement logically conclude this. ALso, there is prophetic saying that suggest conditional forgiveness. Eg see https://sunnah.com/bukhari:6534
-
Please also refer to the video below from 54:10 to 56:07
-
Assalam alaikum, Okay Brothers , Hadith and derivative from Quranic understanding is the basis for Huqooqul ibaad.This is nothing but human logic reasoning and just disposition made to derive at . Any way I would like to know how this law will be applied in the case of adultary. In other matters if one wants he or she can set the things right but how can he or she do so in the case of adultary ? If he or she keep quiet in this world without seeking expiation have they to lose every thing in the hereafter? How one can obtain Talafi in this world in this regard since it’s a sensitive matter, more over Allah Swt kept it secret . So what will be the modalities to adopt? Please clarify? I think this subject comes under huqooqu allah . Allah Swt if He wills He can forgive whom so ever He wish as per his law . I think one has to seek Allah Swt forgiveness in this regard . Please clarify ?
-
Very true, one has to seek Allah’s forgiveness for every sin regardless
But every sin related to people can not be eradicated by asking forgiveness from the concerned individual. It’s particularly true in personal/sensitive matters.
I don’t think there’s any clear directive in Quran/sunnah for this. The reason is apparent, human intellect can decide what to do in this matter. If a husband has cheated on his wife and repented then he should ask forgiveness from Allah and be extra kind to his wife. Forgive her mistakes as much as possible and hopefully she’ll forgive him on judgement day
-
Assalam alaikum dear brothers , why can’t you moderators instead of ignoring or over looking the vital subject elicit yourself or solicit the expert opinion of our Ustaad Javeed Ahmed Ghamidi saheb on this critical subject and make known to the members as well as for those who are in need of guidance in this regard . it will be of great help , guidance and needful for so many people. Hope you will do the needful in this regard. Jazakallahukhair
-
Ghamidi sahab has already clearly stated his point that if God so wills, He can forgive any sin, however, He will not forgive any matters where the right of another person has been violated until that person also forgives.
In matters where a sin has been committed against God, especially where there’s no remediation prescribed, our only option is to sincerely repent, continually seek God’s forgiveness, and hope that He will forgive.
Please note that all questions where Ghamidi sahab’s feedback is required are already sent through the proper channel. However, the list of such questions is very long and it keeps growing despite our best effort as well as that of Ghamidi sahab. The moderators here are students of Ghamidi sahab, most of whom have been learning from him for a very long time, and make their best effort to responsibly answer any questions according to Ghamidi sahab’s viewpoint. Should someone still need to directly ask a question to Ghamidi sahab, they always have the option to register for the next Ask Ghamidi Live event through this app.
-
Assalam alaikum, The reply given is not addressing fully the concern subject which i raise. Always make sure that You touch or stick to the topic which asked for . No doubt we are all learner’s and nobody is perfect we are all trying our level best to be so. we’re all fortunate enough to have services of Ustaad Javeed Ahmed Ghamidi saheb at our disposal. Since you are very near to him you can solicit his opinion on our behalf at least where it’s require . Please try to do so when ever the topic is not of personal in nature, universal and it is useful for all Is it not a good work which can lift your ranks in the hereafter? Kindly address if you have time and space at your disposal. Jazakallahukhair
-
As Faisal sb mentioned, you can directly ask this question to Ghamidi sb by registering for ask ghamidi live event. Refer to following link
Discussion 53183
-
-
In recent Q&A Session with Ghamidi Sahab on Questions selected from ASK GHAMIDI Platform:
For answer to your question, please refer to the video below from 0:53:49 to 1:05:13
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
