Part 1 – Episode 58

00:00- Introduction

03:00- What make you differ from the majority opinion on the matter of music? Halal O Haram wrt verse 7:33

23:15- If we try to understand principle then there will be no obidience so why insist on understanding principle?

35:01- What if a scholar intfer from verse in prohibiton of some practice? Quranic verse about poetry in Surah shura

https://youtu.be/CKbgZ8Fv3Do

Part 2 – Episode 59

00:00- Summary for Previous episode

13:00- Comment on Surah Jumma ayah 9-11 in context of prohibition of lawful thing at certain time.

22:28- If usage is questionable then why music is not mentioned in Quran in this context?

25:23- Ghamidi sb understanding of verse 31:6

58:49- What does Shah Abdul Qadir sb says about 31:6

https://youtu.be/bZ2JZGg0W2s

Part 3 – Episode 60

00:00- Ghamidi sb comments on verse 17:64

18:10- Why Ibne Abbas and others interpreted 17:64 as tools of music?

22:26- Music is generally used for other purposes then rememberence of God so why it will not be considered prohibited?

26:32- Ghamidi sb comments on verse 25:72

40:00- Ghamidi sb comments on verse 53:59-61

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YVQLp0nFxSo

Part 4 – Episode 61

00:00- General comments on hadiths about Music

15:50- Quran do not allow music, tv etc so why it would be considered lawfull?

19:00- Comment on Bukhari:1309 (https://sunnah.com/bukhari:3091)

34:09- Why Sahaba were drinking alcohol in Madina?

https://youtu.be/0q7UiBGEEkM

Part 5 – Episode 62

00:00- Summary of the Ghamidi sb point of view

7:46- How come you can say music things are lawful?

14:42- Comments on Hadith Musanad Ahmed # 4533 or https://sunnah.com/abudawud:4924

22:08- Which principle is applicable to mentioned hadith?

28:13- How you can say that the sahaba misunderstood the prophet action?

29:44- Comments on Hadith Musanad Ahmed #8783 or https://sunnah.com/mishkat:3895, https://sunnah.com/muslim:2114

32:40- Comments on Hadith Musanad Ahmed #7586 or https://sunnah.com/nasai:5222, https://sunnah.com/abudawud:2554

41:54- Comments on Hadith Musanad Ahmed #25168

https://youtu.be/Yj5qUMkAHq8

Part 6 – Episode 63

00:30- Preliminary points about permissiblity of music/art in current time

5:43- Comments on Hadith Bukhari # 5590, https://sunnah.com/bukhari:5590

28:26- Comments on Hadith Musanad Ahmed# 15720

40:36- In reference to Hadith Musanad Ahmed# 15720, may be this was a way to tell singing is an act of devil?

41:51- Musical instrument are like flute etc, how can you say pot is musical instrument?

https://youtu.be/4Z2Bokdt-DY

Part 7 – Episode 64

00:30- Comment on Hadith Musand Ahmed#23011 or https://sunnah.com/tirmidhi:3690

15:50- What is Ghamidi sb comment about on permissibility of duff?

20:00- Comment on Hadith Nisai#4236

23:31- What is Religious mind?

25:18- Comment on Hadith Ibne Majah# 1899, https://sunnah.com/ibnmajah:1899

27:51- Comment on Hadith Ibne Majah #1897, https://sunnah.com/ibnmajah:1897

32:40- Comment on Hadith Bukhari# 5162, https://sunnah.com/bukhari:5162

36:39- Comment on Hadith Ibne Majah #1900, https://sunnah.com/ibnmajah:1900

39:45- Comment on Hadith Musand Ahmed#18280

https://youtu.be/c8Yj6KqM7qk

Part 8 – Episode 65

00:30- Comment on Hadith Bukhari# 952,https://sunnah.com/bukhari:952

9:30- Why only slave girl use to sing. why not respectable people?

10:55- Can we stop people to singing based on sadde zariya?

14:30- Comment on Hadith Nasai# 5539

21:33- Why there is difference in understanding of sahaba?

24:01- Why Sahaba donot enforce such opinion?

26:30- Comment on Hadith Musanad Ishaq bin Rahwia#624, similar hadith https://sunnah.com/muslim:793e, https://sunnah.com/tirmidhi:3855

30:10- Hazrat Daud use to play instrument, why prophet Mohammad saw didnt?

31:50- Comment on Hadith Sahih Ibne haban 892

34:49- Comment on Hadith Bukhari# 7544 https://sunnah.com/bukhari:7544

36:57- Comment on Hadith Musanad Ahmed#13377

40:19- Comment on Hadith Nasai# 8193

https://youtu.be/l_rZRcY3aOc

Part 9 – Episode 66

00:26- How big is the blessing that we stand on equilibrium and how narrations tell us about that?

4:00- Comment on Hadith Sahih Bukhari # 3034 (sunnah.com/bukhari:3034)

7:00- Comment on Hadith Sahih Muslim # 1802 (sunnah.com/muslim:1802a,sunnah.com/muslim:1802b)

17:12- Comment on Hadith Sahih Ibne Haban # 6272

37:00- Why you didnt commented on this Hadith Sahih Ibne Haban # 6272 at first?

38:28- Why didnt you mentioned zayif hadith in favor of music?

https://youtu.be/lgwSva63MBg

Part 10 – Episode 67

01:00- Why no one looked at this corpus of hadith the way you look at it?

5:44- Why other scholars from maktaba e farahi donot have same approach on it?

9:14- Will you imply same principles on an event with music and women dance?

12:25- Depending on current status of music and art, isnt it better to keep people away from it?

16:53- Comment on notion that Due to Ghamidi sb, the feeling of sin in music listener has eradicated

21:20- Do hadith narration reflect Quranic principles?

25:15- Why there is difference between Prophet (saw)and sahaba and religious mind?

28:03- Can we say that angels are distrubed by noise of todays world?

30:00- What do you think about scientific argument to support religious argument?

36:42- How can decide about the permissiblity on the content of art?

40:28- Explanantion of Ghamidi sb instance on Hadith?

45:06- Advise to people who dont agree with you?

https://youtu.be/eHsk_9mjxLQ