-
15. Variant Readings Of Quran (قراءت قرآنیہ کا اختلاف)– 23 Questions Series
Episode 1- Part 93
00:00- Summary to the topic
2:36- General innate problem in writing a script in language and Question on Preservation of Quran
16:46- Background of the problem of Qiraat
20:00- History of Quran- First era
26:35- Transfer of Prophetic recitation according to Al-Zarkashi book Burhan
29:07- Transfer of Prophetic recitation in first era of Quran history
33:23- The inception of the problem in the first era
43:30- Prophet saw permission to read in any pronunciation with reference to Hadith Abu Daud # 830 https://sunnah.com/abudawud:830
-
14 Replies
-
15. Variant Readings Of Quran (قراءت قرآنیہ کا اختلاف)– 23 Questions Series
updated 2 years, 2 months ago
1 Member
·
14
Replies
-
Episode 2- Part 94
00:00- Summary of previous episode
7:43- Second issue in transfer of Quran due ot forgetting some words
11:02- Comments on Hadith of Sahih Bukhari # 5038 (https://sunnah.com/bukhari:5038)
13:59- Issue of forgetting words/verses
15:52-Comments on Hadith of Musnad Ahmad # 16366
18:46- What mistakes can be done during reciting Quran/
31:20- Rectification of the mistakes with reference to Quran Surah Aala
-
Episode 3- Part 95
00:00- Summary of last episode
3:00- Why there was possiblity of some verses to be forgotten during final recitation by prophet Mohammad saw?
6:00- Allah response to the concern of prophet Mohammad saw about preservation of Quran wrt to Surah Qiyamah verses 16-19?
21:05- How preservation of Quran happened? Reference to Sahih Bukhari # 4997, 4998 (https://sunnah.com/bukhari:4997, bukhari:4998)
25:29- Comments on Bukhari Hadith # 6285 (https://sunnah.com/bukhari:6285) and other hadith about presence of Hazrat Zaid during final recitation
-
Episode 4- Part 96
00:00- Summary of previous episodes
3:40- What recitation and reading was preserved for Quran?
9:42- Comment on Surah Baqarah verse# 213
11:40- Comment on Surah Hadid verse# 25
13:29- What Quran define its own importance wrt Surah Shura verse #17, Surah Furqan verse# 1
19:20- Answer to resason of preservation of Quran
22:30- Why reading of previous book reading was not preserved?
24:38- Reason for end of prophet hood
28:47- What is meant by Qatai dalalah?
33:20- In modern days, we understand on the basis of contents of the book. Why Quran cannot be understood just based on content.
-
Episode 5- Part 97
00:00-Summary of previous episodes
3:50- Difference between Ijma o twattur vs Akhbar-i-Ahad
22:20- introduction to 3rd stage of Quran preservation
-
Episode 6- Part 98
00:00- Summary of previous episodes
4:35- Preservation of Quran by Sahaba
9:00- Preservation of Quran wrt to Sahih Bukhari Hadith # 4986 (https://sunnah.com/bukhari:4986)
28:41- If Paper was available, then why people were writing on palm stalks, stone etc?
32:17- Preservation of Quran wrt to Sahih Bukhari Hadith # 4987 (https://sunnah.com/bukhari:4987)
45:14- Resolving issue of spelling in Quran
48:39- Why hazrat Usman is referred to as Jamal Ul Quran?
50:20- Will Quran be preserved if Caliphs wouldn’t make this decision?
-
Episode 7- Part 99
00:00- Summary of previous episodes
7:28- Qirat of Arza-e-Akhira wrt Jama ul Kalam Hadith # 4564
10:30- Qirat of Arza-e-Akhira wrt Ibn Abi Shaybah hadith # 30922
12:53- Qirat of Arza-e-Akhira wrt Sunan Sa’id ibn Mansur hadith # 97
16:30- Transfer of Qirat of Arza-e-Akhira to Tabaeen wrt an excerpt from Zarkashi book Kitab Al Burhan Fi Ulumil Qur’an
22:40- In the eyes of Sahaba, was content was main thing or recitation?
24:30- Transfer of accent of recitation of Quran wrt an excerpt from Abu Bakr Ibn Mujāhid book Kitab al-sabʿa fil-qirat
-
Episode 8- Part 100
00:00- Summary of last episodes
2:40- Indirect role of Abd al Malik Ibne Marwan in preservation of Quran
22:32- An excerpt from Usul e Ehkam authored by Ibne hazam
24:28- An excerpt from writing of Ibne Khildoon
25:31- Overall analysis on transfer of Quran to Muslims
-
Episode 9- Part 101
00:00- Summary of last episodes
3:34- What is the issue of variation in recitation?
12:29- Analysis on the question of “What to be done with the qiraat before qirat of arza akhira” wrt to Sahih Bukhari hadith #4481 (https://sunnah.com/bukhari:4481, bukhari:5005)
23:58- An excerpt from Al-Jami Ul-Kamil Fi Al-Hadith Al-Sahih Al-Shamil on different recitation
-
Episode 10 – Part 102
00:00- Summary of last episode
2:08- How Akhbar e Ahad become our knowledge?
7:45- Stages in transfer of various recitation to coming generation.
10:17- Names of Famous Qari of recitation
12:57- Concept of Qirat e saba
14:35- Criteria for acceptance of Qirat
17:35- How traditional scholars viewed the various recitation
20:45- An excerpt from Ibne Khaldoon on various recitation.
24:30- What is Ghamidi sb opinion on these recitation
31:51- How Farahi scholars see various recitation.
-
Episode 11 – Part 103
00:00- Intro
1:11- If all variants are accepted how it effect Quran status of Furqan and Burhan
5:07- Example of difference in understanding of Wudu to variant reading in the light of Surah Maida verse 6
24:25- Did Muslims understand this ayah differently?
26:15- Example of difference in understanding of inheritance to variant reading in the light of Surah nisa verse 12
48:34- What is the conclusion of the discussion on inheritance law?
-
Episode 12 – Part 104
00:00- Overview of previous episodes
1:30- Narrating Sahih Bukhari Hadith #2419 https://sunnah.com/bukhari:2419
5:05- Critiquing above mentioned narration.
15:44- Narrating SahihSahih Muslim 820 https://sunnah.com/muslim:820a
19:50- Critiquing above mentioned narration.
22:57- Are these fabricated hadith?How this matter started?
32:00- What is meant by 7 harf?
39:00- why 7?
40:00- Why the world “Unzila” used in the narration?
42:48- Understanding of Harf according to Al-Jamiul Kamil fee Al-Hadith As-Sahih Al-Shamil
47:37- Recitation according to the text of Quran
51:23- Actual reason behind these differences in recitation
-
Episode 13 – Part 105
00:00- Summary of last episode
1:14- Does narrations related to this topic has been confused to be of same event?
2:27- Comments on Incident of Hazrat Umar according to Musanad Ahmed Hadith #16366
6:23- Same incident according to Tabari hadith
8:40- Incident of Ubay bin Kaab from muslim hadith # 821 (https://sunnah.com/muslim:821a)
12:00- Same incident wrt Jamai tirmidhi 2943 (https://sunnah.com/tirmidhi:2943)
15:59- Solving the confusion due to amalgamation of these narrations (excerpt from meezan, https://www.javedahmedghamidi.org/#!/mizan/5aa6a4315e891e8f44a45788?chapterNo=0&subChapterNo=0&subChsecNo=3&lang=ur)
24:58- How these narrations hot mixed up?
-
Episode 14– Part 106
00:00- Intro and Recap of last episode
1:00- Some scholars says these qirats are transferred to ijma o tawatur, how come you say these are akhbar e ahad? An excerpt from zarkashi
11:08- Why you misquote a Abu Abdur rehman bin sulemi and out of context and authencity of this narration
16:11- Why there were some qirat in various city according to research of Mujahid? (https://www.javedahmedghamidi.org/#!/books/5aa66ae35e891e8f44a43f5f?chapterNo=71)
23:33- Why there are qirat of warsh and nafai are recited by people in Maghreb (Morroco Tunisia etc)?
-
Episode 15– Part 107
00:00- Intro
0:46- Why its written Hafs on Quran manuscript? An excerpt from meezan (https://www.javedahmedghamidi.org/#!/mizan/5aa6a4315e891e8f44a45788?chapterNo=0&subChapterNo=0&subChsecNo=3&lang=ur)
15:35- What if some one copy Quran in different reading, will it make any difference?
17:20- if Quran is protected why there are difference in spelling or reading?
19:48- In era of Hazrat Uthman, everything was finalized how can we allow room for change in reading?
21:36- What about the manuscript of Ibne Masud where we find differences in arrangement of Quran?
24:42- If some surah missing, will we say Quran is not preserved?
25:46- Comments on Ibne Masud opinion that Surah Nas and Falq are not part of Quran
27:30- Comments onopinion of Ibne Abbass on compilation of Quran.
29:45- Does Imam frahi know more Arabic then Ibne Abbass?
30:42- What is meant by protecting of Quran by Allah and it application to variant reading?
32:30- What is conclusion of your talk?
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
The discussion "15. Variant Readings Of Quran (قراءت قرآنیہ کا اختلاف)– 23 Questions Series" is closed to new replies.
