-
Praying Duhur In Asr Congregation
Assalamualaikum
First, what’s the decisive thing in congregation prayer. Like the niyah (intention) of Imam or the individual person?
Secondly, if Imam is leading Maghrib and i do Qada of Asr behind him knowingly that he is leading Maghrib, then is my Asr acceptable? And if i do that unknowingly?
Thirdly: if Imam is leading Zuhur and i prayed both Zhuhur and Asr in Zuhurs time. I prayed Zuhur by myself and Asr behind the Imam leading Duhur? Knowingly and unknowingly?
Please answer with evidence? Thanks.
-
1 Reply
-
Praying Duhur In Asr Congregation
updated 2 years, 6 months ago
2 Members
·
1
Reply
-
Doing something unknowingly incurs no ruling unless it comes to your notice. If it comes to your notice then you can redo it if the time for the prayer is still there. if not, then what is done, is done. No need to bother about it.
No one does such things knowingly. It is your intention that matters. You cannot say Asr prayer at the time of Maghrib. The prayers we combine for some reasons are Zuhar- Asr, and Maghrib – Isha. You cannot say one prayer behind an Imam who is saying some other prayer. Prayer of Imam and Muqtadi should be the same if it is a Fard prayer.
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
