-
17. What Is Sunnah? (سنّت کیا ہے ؟ )–Response To 23 Questions
Episode 1- Part 115
Thread: Discussion 56177
00:00- Overview of objection on Ghamidi sb stance on Sunnat
1:51- Preamble to Ghamidi sb’s stance on Sunnat
8:36- An excerpt from Meezan about the source of deen and objective
17:26- Definition of Ummi
18:30- Continuation of excerpt
22:54- How did deen reach us?
26:03- Imam Shafai’s definition of Ilm -e- amma
29:33- Definition of Established History
-
18 Replies
-
17. What Is Sunnah? (سنّت کیا ہے ؟ )–Response To 23 Questions
updated 1 year, 5 months ago
2 Members
·
18
Replies
-
Episode 2- Part 116
00:00- Recap of the previous episode
0:54- What is ijma o twattur and its logic?
4:00- Contribution of Imam Shafai in defining Ilm ul Aama
29:00- Final Comments
-
Episode 3- Part 117
00:00- Recap of previous episodes
1:00- Did the ummah similarly appreciate the concept of sunnah as Ghamidi sb?
2:27- The idea of ilm e tawattur, according to imam sarakhsi
13:31- Examples of ilm e tawattur
18:00- Is it possible to convey the same message throughout generations?
29:04- Wisdom behind tawattur of religion?
-
Episode 4- Part 118
00:00- Recap of previous episodes
1:19- Khabr e Twattur, according to Ibn e Hazam
9:51- Some examples, given by Ibn e Hazam, to illustrate the point?
17:35- Is tawattur a source of knowledge?
21:00- Transfer of knowledge of language and history through twattur.
32:40- Excerpt from the writings of Allama Aamdi on twattur
43:00- Conclusion of the excerpts cited in the episode
-
Episode 5- Part 119
00:00- Quick recap
1:16- Transmission of knowledge through masses is not according to modern scientific methods. How can an everyday person study sunnah?
6:53- Didn’t the Camera replace the transmission chain?
8:59- The camera has a GPS, which eradicates doubts.
13:40- Trusting James-Webb telescope for the universe?
15:00- Trusting instruments for predictions?
18:05- Why is there not a possibility of error in transmission?
22:45- Deceiving millions of people is still possible today; how can we trust old traditions?
28:11- Why is sunnah superior to reasoning?
30:18- Petra has been scientifically shown as the real Mecca; why trust sunnah?
32:35- Does transmission of people capable of transmitting complex ideas of religion?
39:32- Why differentiate between pre-historic and historical periods?
42:21- Wouldn’t Biddat become common as many people follow them?
45:12- What if the established history turns out to be false?
48:08- How many people are required to make something as established history?
51:13- What about fake news without any evidence as happening in Pakistan?
52:58- Can’t govt enforce their orders to replace the tradition, for instance, qirat in Morocco.
-
Episode 6- Part 120
00:00- What has been transferred to us by Prophet Mohammad saw?
14:15- Comments on Quranic verses 6:83-90
24:06- Comments on Quranic verses 16:120-123
28:32- Was their tradition and books transmitted by previous prophets?
34:24- Quran (42:52) says the prophet knew nothing about Iman; how is it possible?
36:20- An excerpt from meezan chapter sunnat
-
Episode 7- Part 121
0:42- Is there any other scholar who agrees with your stance about sunnat?
10:25- Excerpts from Shah Waliullah’s book Hujjat-ul-Baligha volume 1.
41:26- Concluding remarks on the excerpts
-
Episode 8- Part 122
00:47- What is suunat according to you wrt an excerpt from meezan?
6:05- Tajdeed, islah and izafa in sunnat by Prophet Mohammad saw
19:00- Rational for the differences in shariah of different prophets and izafa in sunnat eg Eid ul Fitr and Eid ul Adha
27:00- Redefining Sunnat wrt excerpt from meezan with the concept of islah, izada and tajdeed
30:38- Wasn’t tajdeed and islah in sunnat done by Quran?
33:54- Need of the rulings of the Quran for society
35:35- How is sunnah inferred?
-
Episode 09 – Part 123:
0:33- What acts can be considered sunnah?
4:55- Sunnah of worship (an excerpt from meezan)
7:26- Sunnah of Namaz/Salah (an excerpt from meezan)
13:43- Sunnah of Zakat (an excerpt from meezan)
18:14- Sunnah of Roza/ Soum
21:07- Sunnah of Hajj and umrah
25:25- Sunnah of Qurbani
27:09- Sunnah of Nikah
32:50- Sunnah of edible items
37:16- Sunnah of Etiquettes
39:10- Halal concept in Jews?
-
Episode 10 – Part 124:
00:50- Etiquettes for nikah and allowed relationships
2:18- Sunnah of eating with Allah’s name and eating with the right hand
3:23- Sunnah of saying Salam while meeting Muslims
5:21- Sunnah of saying yerhamkullah and alhamdullilah
7:55- Sunnah of cleanliness of body
9:49- An excerpt from almufasir fi tarikh ul arab qabl Islam to depict pre-islamic customs
15:27- General discussion about the customs
19:05- Comparison of Quran and Sunnah transfer
21:46- Preamble to Principles of determining sunnah
23:46- Is every sect united for these sunnah?
-
Episode 11 – Part 125:
00:49- Principles of determining Sunnah
2:35- What is Sunan?
3:00- First principle “Sunnah should be part of religion”
20:26- The second principle is “Sunnah should be an action”
31:45- The third principle, “Quran cannot start sunnah”
-
Episode 12 – Part 126
00:35- Nawafil ibadat being termed as sunnah
4:58- Confusion between Uswa Hasna and Sunnah
6:15- The Fourth Principle of determining Sunnah (https://www.javedahmedghamidi.org/#!/mizan/5aa6a4315e891e8f44a45788?chapterNo=0&subChapterNo=1&subChsecNo=3&lang=ur_
16:16- Why abolution is considered sunnah despite mentioned in Quran
17:39- Incident of asking a sahaba to offer prayer again
-
Episode 13 – Part 127
00:00- Need of 5th Asool for determining sunnat?
3:53- Role of Fitrah in deen
6:00- Examples leading to this rule.
17:20- If Islam is deen fitrat, why say Qurani or prophetic command?
20:02- The fifth principle (https://www.javedahmedghamidi.org/#!/mizan/5aa6a4315e891e8f44a45788?chapterNo=0&subChapterNo=1&subChsecNo=4&lang=ur#fn_44)
23:40- Explanation of the principle
-
Episode 14 – Part 128
00:00- Need for defining 6th principle.
9:42- Examples of advice given by the Prophet saw
11:28- How to determine if it’s deen or advise?
14:52- The sixth principle for determining sunnah (https://www.javedahmedghamidi.org/#!/mizan/5aa6a4315e891e8f44a45788?chapterNo=0&subChapterNo=1&subChsecNo=5&lang=ur)
21:29- Examples to explain the principle
29:00- If Prophet saw showed interest in certain acts, why shouldn’t a person follow them?
-
Episode 15 – Part 129
00:00- Defining terms bayan e rasool, Uswah and seerat.
4:00- What is Sunnat?
8:30- Stating 7th principle ( https://www.javedahmedghamidi.org/#!/mizan/5aa6a4315e891e8f44a45788?chapterNo=0&subChapterNo=1&subChsecNo=6&lang=ur)
19:52- Can sunnah be transmitted through khabr e wahid?
-
Episode 16 – Part 130
00:00- Recap of previous episodes
1:05- Definition of Sunnah
1:46- Criteria for an act are ijma, tawattur and sunnah
9:45- Why verify an absolute thing with weak evidence?
17:00- Is the nature of sunnat also transmitted through ijma?
21:32- Why is wuzu suunat despite being started by Quran?
26:19- Prayers of Jumma and Eid were started later by Prophet Saw; how is it sunnah?
-
Episode 17 – Part 131
00:00- Recap of the Previous episode0:45- Sadqah fitr was not started by Hazrat Ibrahim As; how is it sunnah?
3:21- Fasting was obligated by Quran; how is it sunnah?
6:40- If fasting is transferred through ijma and tawattur, why are there differences in timing?
7:49- Why are there differences in opinion about women keeping fast?
9:03- Why are there differences in opinion about the ethics of Qurbani?
10:15- How is Takbeerat sunnah?
11:05- What makes divorce a sunnah?
14:40- Why is Muhrammat sunnah?
16:22- Muhrammat is also held by non-muslims then; why it’s not fitrah?
17:35- How is meher sunnah?
18:10- Is Establishing the relationship between husband and wife in a certain time sunnah based on purity?
19:17- Why can’t women fast in those days?
20:15- Why can’t we say that Quran initiated the prohibition of food items?
23:30- If tazkiya and tasmiyah are sunnah, then why differences of opinion?
24:33- Use of right hand while eating is sunnah; how?
26:30- What makes using the right-hand worship?
27:39- If all Muslims do not do certain practices, how is transferred?
28:49- How certain duas become sunnah?
30:02- How is Trimmed moustache sunnah?
30:40- Trimming pubic hair is sunnah; how?
31:50- Circumcision is sunnah; how?
34:26- Why is Circumcision of women not sunnah?
35:13- Washing mouth and body is sunnah; how?
39:14- How does festival become sunnah?`
-
Episode 18 – Part 132
00:00- Recap of the Previous episode
00:54- if it’s simple, why are there differences between you and scholars?
3:00- Comments on an excerpt from the book maqamat (https://www.javedahmedghamidi.org/#!/books/5aa66ae35e891e8f44a43f5f?chapterNo=22)
7:16- How Ulema differentiate between sunnah and uswa w.r.t. book of Ibn ‘Abd al-Barr?
11:10- Can the literal meaning of Sunnah be used for both uswa and religious directive
12:35- Why are you different from the rest of Ummah?
-
Episode 19 – Part 133
00:00- Recap of the Previous episode
1:35- How are there three sources of deen outside the Quran?
5:32- Comments on an excerpt from Meezan about sunnah?
8:43- Why not say everything we received from Prophet termed as Uswa?
12:29- Why you removed certain acts from the sunnah list later on?
15:08- Why is sunnah doubtful though it has been transferred with the same method of the Quran?
17:20- If sunnah is authoritative, why are differences in the list of sunnah?
20:57- Are there changes in the sunnah list by previous scholars?
22:32- Why do you not mention the definition of Imam Shafai of ilm ul Amma?
25:13- Why do you cite the bible as a source for sunnah?
26:58- What will you advise?
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
The discussion "17. What Is Sunnah? (سنّت کیا ہے ؟ )–Response To 23 Questions" is closed to new replies.
