-
Modern Nation States
World Superpowers | موجودہ عالمی طاقتیں | ماضی اور حال
00:49- What is the difference between secular and religious states?
2:46- Difference between Atheist and agnostics
4:34- How to get out of the problems in the Muslim world.
9:58- What types of relations should we have with the West?
14:28- How civilised are the western states?
17:55- What is Knowledge and its limits?
23:20- Which one was better Banu Ummaya or Banu Abbass
29:53- How Fiqh Hanafi come into existence?
30:55- Deducing Principles from the event?
33:56– Why is there shirk in south Asian countries?
36:36– Can a religious argument be a logical argument?
42:02– What type of pact was made in Ahd e Alast
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w__EFgsLwEs
![World Superpowers | موجودہ عالمی طاقتیں | ماضی اور حال | Javed Ghamidi | Hassan Ilyas | Ilmo Hikmat]()
-
4 Replies
-
Modern Nation States
updated 1 year, 8 months ago
1 Member
·
4
Replies
-
The drawbacks of the nation-state | قومی ریاست کے مفاسد کیوں بیان نہیں ہوتے؟
00:00:00 – Introduction to the discussion on Israel’s recognition and the concept of nation-states.
00:00:54 – Critique of the idealized vision of nation-states vs. the reality of oppression and conflict.
00:01:25 – Questioning the acceptance of current borders (e.g., 1928 agreements) and Muslim objections.
00:02:23 – Historical context: Ottoman Empire’s defeat and how Western powers reshaped the world order.
00:03:14 – Consequences of artificial borders: Resource disparities and human suffering.
00:04:02 – How can Muslims improve their condition under the existing system?
00:05:09 – Nation-states as a human construct (not divinely ordained) and their flaws.
00:05:46 – Islamic perspective on nation-states: No inherent objection, but criticism of injustices.
00:06:31 – Desire for a borderless world, but current reality requires working within the system.
00:07:14 – Nation-states are not inherently anti-Islamic; focus should be on reforming injustices.
00:07:52 – Example: Pakistan’s creation as a nation-state and its challenges.
00:08:26 – Power dynamics: Who controls global order? Muslims lack influence.
00:08:59 – Afghanistan case study: Taliban’s attempt to redefine governance vs. international norms.
00:10:06 – Cultural vs. religious conflicts (e.g., hijab bans in France, tribal norms in Afghanistan).
00:10:37 – State authority vs. personal freedoms: Should governments enforce cultural/religious norms?
00:11:16 – Legal vs. moral issues: States should not legislate personal beliefs.
00:11:55 – Corruption accusations: Burden of proof lies on the accuser, not the accused.
00:12:52 – Due process in financial scrutiny – Example: Proving unexplained wealth.
00:13:19 – Fair investigations require evidence, not assumptions.
00:14:06 – Legal accountability must follow proper procedure, not public shaming.
00:15:08 – Conclusion: Justice demands proof, not baseless allegations.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cW3a0xmV6HY
![The drawbacks of the nation-state | قومی ریاست کے مفاسد کیوں بیان نہیں ہوتے؟ | Javed Ahmed Ghamidi]()
-
![The Pillars of Nation State | قومی ریاست کا قیام اور اس کے عناصر | Javed Ghamidi | Hassan Ilyas |P-2]()
-
![The Pillars of Nation State | قومی ریاست کا قیام اور اس کے عناصر | Javed Ghamidi | Hassan Ilyas |P-3]()
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
The discussion "Modern Nation States" is closed to new replies.
