-
Sunnah
Question 1: Sunnah sirf Amali tawatur hai? Kya isme Qoli tawatur nhi? Jese Qabristan main dakhil hote waqt Asslamualaikum kehna ya khana shuru krne se pehle Bismillah kehna.
Question 2: Agr Allah taala ne Sunnat ki zimmedari nhi li to iska matlab sunnat main koi farq nhi ana chahiye to Kya jo aj hum 5 waqt ki namaz pdh rhe hain kya ibrahim AS k daur main bhi 5 he namazein thi?
-
8 Replies
-
Sunnah
updated 8 months, 1 week ago
4 Members
·
8
Replies
-
کھانا وغیرہ شروع کرنے سے پہلے تسمیہ پڑھنا عمل ہے۔ یہ زبان کا عمل ہے۔
سنت متواترہ بھی محفوظ صورت میں ہم تک پہنچی ہے۔
نمازیں ہمیشہ سے یہی پانچ رہی ہیں۔ ابو داؤد کی روایت میں واضح طور پر بتایا گیا ہے جب جبرائیل علیہ السلام نے آپ کو نماز اور اس کے اوقات بتائے تو ساتھ میں یہ بھی بتایا کہ یہی تمام انبیا کی نماز تھی۔
-
کیا ایسا ممکن ہے کے پہلے کے دور میں نمازوں کی گنتی ۵ سے کم یا زائد تھی ؟ جو بخاری میں حدیث ہے ۵۰ نمازوں والی اسکو آپ کیسے سمجھتے ہیں؟ کیا ایسا نھی ہو سکتا کے اللّٰہ نے اس سنت میں تبدیلی کی ہو؟
-
The narration about 50 salats is not authentic. When God issues a commandment, he does not negotiate with his creations, even if they are Prophets. Please refer to verse 11:76,
Qur 11:76 “O Abraham, turn away from this. The command of your Lord has been passed, and a retribution that will not be turned back is coming for them.”
The narration about 50 prayers is nothing but an invented story.
Zoroastrians pray five times a day. While in Judaism, the number of daily prayers is three. Some people argue that number of prayers in Judaism was originally five. But this is a speculation, and not grounded in proper evidence. The preponderance of evidence, both from Bible and Talmud suggests that the number of prayers in Judaism has been three, practiced to this day. Please see Psalms 55:18, Daniel 6:11.
Please note that SunnatuAllah (God’s law, way of dealing) is immutable and does not change (33:62, 35:43, 17:77, 48:23). Whereas, salat is a commandment or an act of worship prescribed by God, and God’s commandments towards humans changed with time in past. For instance, with respect to the mandate of Jesus, please see verse 3:50:
Qur 3:50 “And authenticating what is between my hands of the Torah, and to make lawful some of that which was made unlawful to you; and I have come to you with a sign from your Lord, so be aware of God and obey me.”
Also see verse 4:160 which tells that God changed certain laws for Jews because of their wickedness:
Qur 4:160 Because of the wickedness from those who are Jews, We made forbidden to them the good things that were lawful to them, and for their deterring many from the path of God.
-
-
Please see video From 29:44 and onwards
-
تو کیا اسکا یہ روایت صحیح ہے یا نہی ؟ @codename.AJK
-
Ghamidi sb ky mutabik yeah riwayat theek hai… lekin kyunki yeah roya tha is liye us ki interpretation zaroori hai.
-
-
جواب مل گیا ہے۔ آپ سب کا بیحد شکریہ
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
