-
Sahih Bukhari 2324
Sahih bukhari hadith 2324 is classified as authentic and it qualifies the sanad and matan. My question is if a hadith is authentic in its every aspect but doesn’t qualify the standard of intellect, would it be considered sahih? (For reference see the mentioned hadith)
Your views please? @UmerQureshi sb @Irfan76
-
1 Reply
-
Sahih Bukhari 2324
updated 9 months ago
2 Members
·
1
Reply
-
To be Sahih al Sanad (authentic) does not mean a hadith is correct too. A hadith is judged for its chain of narration and for its text which should not go against intellect, the Quran, established historical facts, etc. The details are there in the book of Uloom ul Quran.
There are two possibilities about the above-cited hadith. It is allegorical to tell some simple lessons or it is narrated from Israelite stories because Abu Hurairah sometimes ascribed narration from Israelites to the holy prophet.
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
