-
A Directive In Hadith Based On Sadd E Zariya Phenomena
sir it is told that not everything leads to Haram is to be avoided on the grounds of Sadd e Zariya.
my question is, if some directive which is based on Sadd e Zariya is given to us in Sunnah and Quran, then intentional violations of it will be minor sin.
but if for example a command comes to us in Khabr e Ahad, or Hadith, which is also not linked to a command of Quran separately. where the prophet is telling people to not to do something because of its potential to lead to some bad. will a person also be sinful if he didn’t follow what the Hadith said?.
-
3 Replies
-
A Directive In Hadith Based On Sadd E Zariya Phenomena
updated 10 months, 4 weeks ago
2 Members
·
3
Replies
-
It is our moral sense which tells what is sinful. It doesn’t matter it is mentioned in hadith or we find it inappropriate on our own.
-
@Irfan76 for example sir, we hear a hadith that prophet said to extinguish any lamp fire before sleeping because of risk of a mouse catching the fire and risking the whole tent.
if a person who does live in tent right now, uses lamp fire, but he doesn’t extinguish it while sleeping because he likes to sleep in a little bit of light up environment. after reading this hadith, if he still continue to does it. will he be sinful for disregarding prophet’s words?. in a sense that if prophet have a suggestion, will it be sin to not follow the suggestion or words of prophet?
-
Suggesting is not a directive, therefore it is not sinful if one does otherwise.
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
