-
Plagiarism Allegations
I ask Ghamidi sb to respond to allegation of plagiarism in Quran by some people like Sameer https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4mqZqf8nQH0&t=1s in the light of historical facts. At some places he also claims that there are scientific errors but i think it needs some scholarly response.
best regards
Ijaz
-
2 Replies
-
Plagiarism Allegations
updated 11 months, 4 weeks ago
2 Members
·
2
Replies
-
It is not new to make some arrangements of words to imitate an expression. It does not make two expressions similar or equal. If such mimicry had any value, it should have been adopted by the critics and kept against the Quran to nullify its challenge that its like cannot be produced. To date, there is no piece, that could pass the test of literary merits, meaningfulness, and inherent wisdom, to claim that it is equal to the Quran. In the pieces cited in the video, musicality is questionable, let alone the meanings that holds no
The Quran is not just an expression of beautiful words, it contains knowledge of history, prediction of the future that came true, tells the ways of God according to which the fate of nations run, and thematic coherence that runs across the surahs and the Quran, etc. All this came from a person who had no background in poetry, literary activities, or religious and historical knowledge.
-
Thank you for your reply. Jazakallah
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
