-
Insisting On Minor Sin
Insisting on minor sin make someone kafir?
If someone think I am not commiting major sin and I am insisting minor sin without felling guilty.
Like doing and doing without felling guilty or forgiveness from allah.
Because gamdi Sahab ne bolla tha minor sin lead major sin.
Ager koi minor sin korke major sin sexy bach gea toh allah forgive that.
If I think like that I am comit minor sin but not commit major sin.
This thing make me kafir.
In one question ans someone comment that minor sin kahbi khabi sarkwasi ki taraf Le jatti hay.
-
5 Replies
-
Insisting On Minor Sin
updated 2 weeks, 6 days ago
4 Members
·
5
Replies
-
کفر کا مطلب ہے کہ خدا کی بات کو جان کر یہ خدا کا حکم ہے، آدمی ماننے سے انکار کر دے۔
عام مسلمان حکم کا انکار نہیں کرتے، بلکہ اس پر عمل نہ کرنے کی ضد کر لیتے ہیں۔ اس سے وہ گناہ گار ہو جاتے ہیں۔ یہ ضد کبیرہ گناہوں میں ہو تو کفر بن جاتی ہے اور صغیرہ گناہوں میں ہو تو صرف گناہ ہی رہتی ہے۔ اگرچہ یہ بھی ایک درجہ کا کفر ہے مگر خدا نے صغیرہ گناہوں کو کفر قرار نہیں دیا۔
-
I’m from Bangladesh I can’t read Urdu
-
Following is the English Translation of what Dr. Irfan Shahzad Sahab wrote:
“Kufr (disbelief) signifies that when a person recognizes a command as being from Allah, yet knowingly rejects it and refuses to accept it, such denial constitutes kufr.
Ordinary Muslims, however, do not usually deny the divine command itself; rather, they persist in neglecting to act upon it. This obstinacy renders them sinful. If such defiance pertains to major sins (kabair), it can amount to kufr; whereas if it relates to minor sins (Saghair), it remains a sin without reaching the level of kufr. Although in a broad sense, this obstinacy may be described as a form of kufr, but God has not classified minor sins as kufr.“
-
But in Quran it is stated that they denied and disbelieved and it is not mentioned that whether it is major or minor sin so wouldn’t denying anything be kufr? Also you said that Muslims don’t deny they just don’t act on the order what’s the difference between both
-
-
In the Qur’an, the term Kuffar refers to those who reject God’s message and His messenger. This rejection is considered a major sin, involving shirk and outright denial of God.
Kufr means to deny God or His command openly, without excuse, remorse, or acknowledgment of belief—essentially a complete refusal to accept Him or His rulings.
However, failing to obey a command due to weakness, an excuse, or while expressing humility, regret, etc., is not considered kufr.
An analogy can be drawn from legal systems: there is a difference between committing a minor offense and committing treason.
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
