Prohibiting Lesbianism When There Is Nothing Impure About This Relationship

[Ahsan]

question?

[Daniyaa Khan]

The reason why it a sin and impure? it present in male-male relationship because they use impure way what about female-female relationship because they can’t use any impure way there must be other reasons its not convincing

[Ahsan]

See Discussion 66225

[Daniyaa Khan]

Sir I have read this thread I get it, its lie in the category of fawahish that why it’s a sin but how its impure act for female-female which they give reason for male-male.

[Umer]

At an epistemological level, Fawahish refers to acts of sexual impurity whether it be related to that of a mind or a body.

Lesbianism includes sexual impurity of mind.

For further details, please refer to the following response of Ghamidi Sahab:

Discussion 52205 • Reply 52215

[Mohammed Zubair Alam]

But how do we determine that leasbianism is a sexual impurity of the mind when the body is not included?

Also If a person doesn’t feel any impurity in her mind?.

How can we create this concept of impurity in everyone’s mind when the principle of the body cannot be applied ?

[Umer]

We are not doing an excercise of making a list and then proving those acts to be impure and hence Fawahish.

‘Fawahish‘ is a well known arabic word and includes fornication, homosexuality, bestiality and all other sins of similar nature. The word فَوَاحِشَ comprehensively includes exposing the private parts before others, spreading details of sexual nature or fornication.

There is no question about it being an act of Fawahish. We are epistemologically reverse-working here just to see which kind of impurity has had already rendered it in Fawahish category.

[Mohammed Zubair Alam]

Ohooo..I got it..thank you so much for such clarity🙏🏻.

[Ahsan]

@UmerQureshi sb can you please respond to that

[Daniyaa Khan]

JAZAK ALLAH

very well explained

Thank you