Killing Today’s Polytheists

[Umer]

This is correct. Our job is to deliver the message to today’s polytheists in the best possible way. What anyone does with that message is not our responsibility.

Those who are killed at the time of prophets are killed with the direct orders of God, and after the last prophet, this will never take place again in this world. The direct addressees of a prophet are not only given clear signs to understand the truth, they are also warned well in advance about how the future shall unfold for the deniers of the truth. All of this it is done with precision that’s way beyond human.

For further explanation, please see

Discussion 1102

[Sameer Bhagwat]

But why would God not kill these polytheists ?

[Umer]

In order to understand that, you’ll have to understand the law of completion of proof (itmam-e-hujjah). I have shared the link to that discussion above.

[Sameer Bhagwat]

I read it but it is inconsistent. When someone denies the message knowing it is true, why God continued his test, just because the messenger is not present ? How is messenger not being present impact the test at all when the person is saying he is convinced that the message is true but he will still deny it.. now what is the point of having the messenger at all when the message is perfectly reached him ? Remember when Prophet sent letters to kings, and after his death, the sahabas attacked those kingdoms, the messenger was not required to be personally present in order to attack and kill those kingdoms.

[Umer]

Your questions are sufficiently addressed in the discussion of completion of proof, link to which is posted above. Please read the text and watch the video.