Preventing Children To Be Out At Maghrib

[Saiyed juned Alimiya]

Khabare vahid he mean hadis me Allah ke rasul se advice aayi he karlo to kher he. Farz wajib jesa koi baat nahi he

[Hamza Ali]

This concept of keeping your kids indoors at Maghrib is extracted from a hadith. It’s not in the Quran though.

[Kiran Sajjad]

Any idea if this hadith is explained by ghamidi sahab or any known scholar in detail?

[Umer]

Just because it is in Hadith, doesn’t necessarily makes it a religious injunction. This hadith also falls within elderly advice by the Prophet (sws) in his capacity as an elder of the society and not in His capacity as a Prophet. Following points must be kept in mind while approaching hadith corpus.

Discussion 32850 • Reply 32869

Ghamidi Sahab hasn’t discussed this specific hadith anywhere to the best of my knowledge.