-
Free Will And Exam (God Guides Whoever He Wills)
allah in the quran chapter 3 verse 39 says, “اللہ جسے چاہتا ہےبھٹکا دیتا ہے اور جسے چاہتا ہے سیدھے رستے پر لگا دیتا ہے”
if it’s allah who wants to distract me what’s the exam for?
why is allah distracting us?
-
9 Replies
-
Free Will And Exam (God Guides Whoever He Wills)
updated 1 week, 1 day ago
2 Members
·
9
Replies
-
Please see Discussion 22255 and Discussion 6805
ask.ghamidi.org
Law Of Guidance And Misguidance - Ask Ghamidi
What is the law defined for guidance and misguidance in the Quran?
-
“اللہ جسے چاہے گمراہ کرے۔ “
why?
sir if we can get a 1 line answer it would be easier because i am getting even more confused reading the whole conversations.
-
For one line answer
“The Quranic law of guidance states that Allah guides those who seek the truth with sincerity and strive towards righteousness. (Quran 29:69)”Brief Explanation:
When Allah says in the Quran that “He guides whom He wills and misguides whom He wills” (e.g., Surah Al-Baqarah 2:272, Surah Al-Qasas 28:56) (Your reference is not correct), it reflects His absolute knowledge and justice. However, this does not mean guidance is arbitrary.
-
Allah provides guidance to those who sincerely seek the truth and strive towards righteousness. (Surah Al-Ankabut 29:69: “And those who strive for Us—We will surely guide them to Our ways.”)
-
Those who turn away from the truth and reject divine guidance are left to their own misguidance. (Surah As-Saff 61:5: “But when they deviated, Allah caused their hearts to deviate.”)
In short, Allah’s guidance is available to all (Quran 2:2), but it depends on one’s sincerity, effort, and willingness to follow the right path.
-
-
in one line answer, it’s talking about those who are shown the right path. I’m talking about those who were distracted.
why were they distracted? i think we should be able to have answer like this
” they were distracted bcz they did xyz thing”
-
Please see the 2nd point in brief explanation for your objection.
If seen in the context the verses don’t imply what you are projecting. For details, you can read al bayan for those verses here
-
almaida 41
“جسے اللہ ہی نے فتنے میں ڈالنے کا ارادہ کر لیا ہو تو اُسے اللہ کی گرفت سے بچنے کے لیے تم کچھ نہیں کر سکتے”
and
“those are the ones for whom allah doesn’t intend to purify their hearts”
these are very clear verses. bhai mera iman kharab horaha😭 ahista ahista.
-
Ap puri verse perhain context clear hojaega. Sirf ek hissay ko nikal ker jo chahay baat ki jaskti hai. Context main perhna zaroori hai ayat ko.
Jo baat ap kehrhay hai us ayat ka chota sa hissa hai woh.Puri ayat yun hai , is ky baad mera previous response dekhay ga. Inshallah baat smjh ajaegi
“اے نبی ﷺ یہ لوگ آپ کے لیے باعث رنج نہ ہوں جو کفر کی راہ میں بہت بھاگ دوڑ کر رہے ہیں ان لوگوں میں سے جو اپنے منہ سے تو کہتے ہیں کہ ہم ایمان رکھتے ہیں مگر ان کے دل ایمان نہیں لائے ہیں اور اسی طرح کے لوگ یہودیوں میں سے بھی ہیں یہ بڑے ہی غور سے سنتے ہیں جھوٹ کو اور یہ سنتے ہیں کچھ اور لوگوں کی خاطر جو آپ کے پاس نہیں آتے وہ کلام کو پھیر دیتے ہیں اس کی جگہ سے اس کا موقع ومحل معیّن ہوجانے کے بعد وہ کہتے ہیں اگر تمہیں یہی (فیصلہ) مل جائے تو قبول کرلینا اور اگر یہ (فیصلہ) نہ ملے تو کنی کترا جانایہ وہ لوگ ہیں کہ جن کے دلوں کو اللہ نے پاک کرنا چاہا ہی نہیں ان کے لیے دنیا میں بھی رسوائی ہے اور آخرت میں بھی ان کے لیے بہت بڑا عذاب ہے
-
let me explain where my issue is.
allah said,”اللہ جسے چاہے گمراہ کرے”
now allah do do Gumrah, that’s for sure. now the question is WHEN.
either before a person’s actions or after his actions or he knows about a persons intentions so he distracts him or us there a certain limit
-
Quran is clear that innate guidance is given to human upon his/her birth. However, further help arrives when a person is sincere in his/her efforts. if one is not interested, then no help from God.
For your confusion, please put the words in context to understand it. Taking words out of context wont help.
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
The discussion "Free Will And Exam (God Guides Whoever He Wills)" is closed to new replies.
