-
Where Are The Ruins Of Thamud And Aad?
What is the evidence that the modern structures found in Arabia are in fact the ruins of these two nations as claimed by Ghamidi sahab in the ask Ghamidi session on May 30th 2021?
-
11 Replies
-
Where Are The Ruins Of Thamud And Aad?
updated 4 years, 2 months ago
3 Members
·
11
Replies
-
I think what ghamidi sb wanted to say that, among arabs these stories has transmitted through oral transmissions. Arabs were aware of those stories and suspected location of origin of these stories
-
The Quran says you walk through their ruins . So where are they?
-
The Prophet and the companions walked through the Madain Saleh ruins on their way back from Tabook. It was referring to that.
-
I sent an article above. How do we know these are the ruins of thamud and sad snd not just some later Nabatean kingdom’
-
Well. There was only one Nabatean kingdom from 400BC to 100AD. Thamud was one city from this kingdom, but I’m not sure if Ad were also from this kingdom or from somewhere else. We know it’s thamud due to hadith
-
According to Ghamidi sahab thamud and aad were pre Abraham so it should be around 3000 BC
-
Maybe true for Ad, but not Thamud.
-
He says it’s for both. I think they used to call thamud the second aad or something. He says both are pre Abraham anyway and the Quran seems to mention both tribes together
-
-
Yes it was the Nabatean kingdom
-
-
When the Prophet went to Tabook, he came across a ruin of the Nabatean Kingdom and pointed out that this was the ruins of the people of Noah.
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
