Salam.

May God have Mercy on you..

Thanks .

yeah,, and Thanks again for showing me where to contact!!, And plss. in the post that i do reference, there is reference of what Ghamidi Sahab said on Concerened Topic.. you can easily find that i articulated Ghamidi Sahab’s words in That Referenced discussion too..

what i articulated there is this :-

“What Ghamidi Sahab had said is this… :- “Only getting registered as a Muslim(Submitted to God) is not enough to enter heaven.” –source :-youtube Video“,,…!

and in this discussion i tried to find his Teaching Further on this topic and i found after hours a Video that i mentioned Above to clearly know his viewpoint..

So yeah Thanks..

<

Yes, i looked into Meezan and Read it’s Index, But there isn’t Mentioning Related to Topic ‘Muslim’.. and yes i Read Al Bayan..

In Meezan, Ghamidi Sahab Explained About Believer(Mu’min) That how if a Person Believe in God then He is Mu’min in view of Quran. and i Agree, But what i am Talking about is word ‘Muslim(Submitted to God)’ and how can it be applied to a Whole Community in which All type(good, bad arrogant) of people exist. and how can all type be Submitted to god!

I am Really Concerned & Serioius About this Topic, Since I Read this Horrible and Shocking Hadith below maybe in last 10 days of Ramadan…

please read..

Sayyiduna Abu Bakrah narrated that a man began to praise another (to his face) in the presence of the Prophetﷺ. so, Heﷺ said, “Wailaka (Woe on you) ! You have cut the neck of your brother!” He said this three times “If any of you must needs praise another, then he should say, ‘I consider him to be such and such, for, Allah is the One (who knows and) who takes account of him(as he knows his reality) If he who praises supposes that the other deserves the praise. (In either case) he must not take upon himself the right to declare anyone pure.”

– Sahih al-Bukhari : 6162 & Mishkat al-Masabih : 4827

And word ‘Muslim (Submitted to God)’ is indeed a praising Word.. By Using Word ‘Muslim’ for People is like that we are guaranteeing that Person or Group of Person that Indeed You Will go To Heaven Because Quran said,

“ [To whom Allah will say], “O My servants, no fear will there be concerning you this Day, nor will you grieve,۝

[You] who believed in Our verses and were Muslims.۝

‘Enter Paradise, you and your spouses: you will be filled with joy.’۝”

-Quran 43:68-70

Yes, Can you See Prophetﷺ used for This ‘way of Praising’ Very Critical and Horrible words that are “Wailaka (Woe on you) ! You have cut the neck of your brother!” He said this three times “ And he Said Three timess. & From other nerrations that i Quoted in previous discussion Prophetﷺ himself didn’t Ever Used word ‘Muslim’ for People Even if they were the People who Prayed behind him..

read this…

“The Prophet (ﷺ) became sick and when his disease became aggravated, he said, “Tell Abu Bakr to lead the prayer.” `Aisha said, “He is a softhearted man and would not be able to lead the prayer in your place.” The Prophet (ﷺ) said again, “Tell Abu Bakr to lead the people in prayer.” She repeated the same reply but he said, “Tell Abu Bakr to lead the people in prayer. You are the companions of Joseph.” So the messenger went to Abu Bakr (with that order) and he led the people in prayer in the lifetime of the Prophet.

-Sahih al-Bukhari : 678

So yeah, Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) even Himself did not Said to ‘lead the Muslim in Prayer’ But he Said lead “the People is Prayer” And he said Two Times. Heﷺ wasn’t Sure that Whether all those who Prayed behind him are really Muslim(submitted to God) or not!!!

This was Enough to Horrify me.. and i thought to Ask about the matter..

~~~~~~

So, If we Take the guidance from Above Hadith, then we should Praise a person & Identify him with his Tribe And Say that :- ‘I Consider That Person of xyz Tribe as a Muslim'(Submitted to God). Because only Allah knows Reality of his heart And anyone Must not take upon himself the right to declare anyone pure.“…

Saying, My Brother is Muslim!, my neighbour is Muslim!, ‘xyz Person’ is Muslim(submitted to God)!, a Group is Muslim!, a Nation or Country is ‘Muslim Country’! is like WE SEVERED & CUT OFF their Necks like Massacre..,, Whenever This Thought Come in my mind i Start Feeling so much Bad and confused that i can’t Describe in words.. i can’t tell u what is Condition of my heart Right now. i really need some Guidance.. I really need Answers For Those 3 Serious Questions.

i Hope, u can understand the severity of Topic.. and Why Prophetﷺ Used those horrible words for Three times…… maybe Heﷺ knew that People would call Themselves by Good names and Honours After Himﷺ without Understanding it.. and will Use in common day language that a “Muslim thief Caught”, And a “Muslim is Criminal” While Even Using Muslim directly is like we severed That xyz person’s neck’.

so Should i only identify a Person with his Tribe’s and ancestor’s name?? as told to us In Quran 49:13!!.. or My whole Understanding is somewhere Wrong.. Then please point me that where i understood something wrong.., i just need Guidance.