-
Silent Rakahs Reciting Quran
According to tawatur and ijma, hasnt it been generationally transferred that we have to read the fatiha in the last two rakahs of silent prayer. How can Ghamidi sahab say that it is just left to ikhtiyaar? @UmerQureshi .
Discussion 47703?action=mark_read&topic_id=47703&reply_id=58028#post-51435 -
4 Replies
-
Silent Rakahs Reciting Quran
updated 3 years, 7 months ago
3 Members
·
4
Replies
-
It is not a matter of ijma and tawatur, it is a simple matter of Akhbar-i-ahad and those narrations themselves are not very concrete in their meaning.
-
I don’t see how this isn’t a piece of knowledge that has been transmitted en Masse generation by generation. How did you learn that you recite fatiha in the last rakah? Your parents and their parents etc etc. This is the exact same argument Ghamidi sahab uses for all other matters of tawatur so why doesn’t it apply here? There is full ijma on this as for tawatur you’d have to consult old fiqh books I guess. Has there ever been any ikhtelaf on this matter?
-
To the best of my knowledge, it is based on Ahad and not on ijma and tawatur. And there are narrations on both practices.
May be Irfan Sahab (@Irfan76 ) can shed further light on the matter.
-
-
This is Ijtihad of some Fuqaha to not to recited a portion of Quran in the thrid and fourth rakaat of Fard prayer, and it is not an agreed upon practice. What we are taught is of the opinion adopted in Hanafid and Maliki school, while the followers of Shafi’i recite a portion of Quran in all three or four rakaat, hence, there is not Ijama and Tawatur on reciting no Quran in the third and fourth rakaat.
One is justified to think that the thrid and fourth rakaat should be the same as the first two.
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
